Summary#
Bill 224, the No Time to Waste Act (Plan for Climate Action and Jobs), 2020, would create three new Acts; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goals include preparing Ontario’s health system for climate-related health risks, setting a climate strategy for the public sector, and developing a proposal to address climate-related threats.
- The Health Minister would have to publish a health action plan within two years, review it at least every four years, and consult named groups when developing or revising it. The plan must cover health risks, vulnerable communities, research programs, health-system preparation, funding and guidance plans, and monitoring.
- The Health Minister would establish a Climate Crisis and Health Secretariat and a science advisory board of 10 to 20 appointed members. The Secretariat’s assigned work includes research, risk tracking, public communication, preparedness plans, training, and technical support for municipalities and First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities.
- The government would have to establish a public-sector climate strategy within one year. The strategy must set out a plan for goals that include capping public-sector greenhouse-gas emissions, reducing them by at least 5 per cent annually until net zero, and setting energy-use targets for certain new public-sector facilities.
- The strategy must include plans for government programs encouraging retrofits and cleaner public-sector vehicles, and purchasing guidelines that consider greenhouse-gas emissions and can disqualify proposals above a set emissions threshold. That threshold cannot be more than 10 per cent above other proposals.
- A select committee of the Legislature would have to produce a climate-threat proposal within six months. The proposal must address threats to Indigenous, racialized and low-income Ontarians; the bill does not require the government to adopt it.
What it means for you#
- Public health and health-care organizations, professionals, and the public: The health plan must set out how climate-health strategies will be communicated to them. It must also provide for monitoring a wide range of health risks, including heat, disease, air and water quality, food insecurity, and impacts on named vulnerable communities.
- Municipalities and First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities: The Secretariat must provide technical assistance and support to assess preparedness and response strategies, as directed by the Health and Environment ministers. The bill does not set out how to request or receive that help.
- Public-sector bodies: The strategy would cover the public sector as defined in the Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act, 1996. It would set goals for emissions and energy use, and require annual public reports on energy use and reductions, with audits. The bill does not itself set a direct fine or other penalty for missing a goal.
- Public-sector suppliers: The strategy’s purchasing guidelines must include emissions as an evaluation factor and provide for disqualifying a proposal that exceeds a specified emissions level. The threshold may be no more than 10 per cent above other proposals.
- The public: The select committee must prepare a proposal, but the bill does not require a public vote on it or require any particular climate action to follow.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The health plan must include a plan for funding and guidance to public health units and health-care facilities, but the bill gives no amount or funding source.
- The bill assigns work to a Secretariat and advisory board and requires research, reporting, and audits, but gives no staffing levels or cost estimates.
- It does not specify the costs of meeting the public-sector strategy’s goals or the effect of its purchasing rules on prices.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set a funding amount, staffing plan, or detailed delivery rules for the health plan, Secretariat, or public-sector strategy.
- The public-sector emissions cap and annual reductions are goals the strategy must plan to achieve. The bill does not specify how emissions will be measured, how progress toward those goals will be enforced, or what happens if a goal is missed.
- Regulations would set some measurement, reporting, audit, and purchasing details. Those regulations are not included here.
- “Net energy consumption is zero” is not defined in the bill. It also leaves the comparison method for new facilities to regulations.
- The bill does not explain how the select committee’s proposal would be considered or put into action.
Case for#
- The health plan is designed to identify climate-related health risks and vulnerable communities, then guide preparation across public health and health care.
- A Secretariat with research, monitoring, communication, and preparedness duties could bring related work together. The bill also requires scientific advice and consultation with affected groups.
- Public-sector emissions and energy goals, along with reporting and audits, could make government activity more measurable and encourage lower-emission purchasing and building practices.
- A cross-party select committee could develop a broad proposal addressing threats to society, the environment, and the economy.
Case against#
- The bill assigns substantial planning, research, reporting, and support work without stating how much it would cost or how it would be staffed.
- Many practical details depend on later regulations or decisions. The bill does not set out a full compliance process or consequences for missing public-sector goals.
- The health plan must include funding and research programs, but the bill does not guarantee a specific amount of funding or that any particular project will be built.
- The select committee must produce a proposal, but there is no requirement for the government to act on it.