Bill would set 75% funding for public health

Summary#

Bill 114, Pandemic Preparedness Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Health Protection and Promotion Act; it would not create a separate pandemic-response agency. Its stated goal is to support pandemic preparedness through regular review of Ontario’s pandemic response plan and changes to how cost-shared public health unit programs and services are funded.

  • The Province would have to provide at least 75 per cent of funding for those programs and services, while municipalities could provide no more than 25 per cent. This rule would apply only if the Legislature appropriates money for it.
  • The Minister of Health would have to establish a Pandemic Preparedness Review Committee, with members appointed from public health experts, pandemic preparedness experts, and community leaders from equity-seeking groups.
  • The committee would review the pandemic response plan every five years, considering developments in public health practice, medical science and technology, and equity.
  • Within 90 days of each committee report, the Minister would have to tell the Legislative Assembly the committee’s findings and make recommendations for the Ontario government to implement. The bill would not require the government to adopt those recommendations.
  • The Act would come into force when it receives Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Municipalities: Their share of funding for the covered programs and services could not exceed 25 per cent, but the funding rule depends on the Legislature appropriating money for it.
  • Province and taxpayers: The Province would be responsible for at least 75 per cent of the covered costs if the funding rule applies. The bill does not set a dollar amount.
  • Public health and pandemic preparedness experts, and equity-seeking communities: Members of these groups could be appointed to the committee. The bill does not require any particular person or community to take part.
  • General public: The bill would create a scheduled review and reporting process. It would not itself change the pandemic response plan, guarantee that recommendations are adopted, or create a new public health service.
  • The current Health Protection and Promotion Act was not supplied, so the existing funding rules and review processes could not be checked against the bill’s proposed changes.

Money#

No publicly available information gives the expected cost of the bill.

  • The bill would require the Province to provide at least 75 per cent of covered public health unit costs, but only if the Legislature appropriates money for that purpose.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set committee members’ pay and expenses. This authority also depends on money being appropriated.
  • The bill gives no cost estimate, funding amount, or staffing figure.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define which public health unit programs and services count as “cost-shared.”
  • It does not say how much money would be appropriated, when it would be available, or how municipalities’ shares would be calculated.
  • It does not specify the committee’s size, appointment process beyond the named groups, or how it would conduct its reviews.
  • It does not require the government to act on the committee’s recommendations.
  • The supplied material does not show how these proposed rules would interact with existing funding or review arrangements.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make pandemic preparedness a recurring task, rather than relying on a one-time review.
  • A committee with public health, pandemic preparedness, and equity perspectives could bring different kinds of knowledge to the review.
  • A provincial funding share of at least 75 per cent could limit the amount municipalities are responsible for paying, if the Legislature provides the money.

Case against#

  • The funding rule depends on future appropriations, so the bill does not guarantee that the Province will provide the required share.
  • The bill requires the Minister to make recommendations, but not the government to adopt them. A review therefore may not lead to changes in the plan.
  • The bill leaves important details—including the committee’s size and review process—to be worked out, and gives no cost estimate.