Mandate Letters Transparency Bill

Summary#

The Publication of Mandate Letters Act, 2022 would amend Ontario’s Executive Council Act and Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. Its stated goal is to require publication of certain mandate letters and prevent one Cabinet-confidentiality exemption from being used to withhold them.

  • The Premier would have to publish each qualifying mandate letter on an Ontario government website as soon as possible, and no later than one week after it is issued.
  • The letters covered are written communications from the Premier to a Cabinet member or Parliamentary Assistant that set out work expectations for advancing the government’s agenda, issued after specified events such as an election, throne speech, appointment or change affecting a Cabinet member.
  • The Premier would also have to publish qualifying letters issued on or after June 7, 2018, within 60 days after the Act comes into force.
  • Under the proposed change to the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, a government office could not use the Cabinet-deliberations exemption alone to refuse to disclose a mandate letter.

What it means for you#

  • The public: Qualifying letters would have to be available on a government website. This would make public the work expectations and policy objectives they set out; it would not guarantee those objectives are achieved.
  • The Premier: Would be responsible for ensuring publication within the bill’s deadlines.
  • Cabinet members and Parliamentary Assistants: Their covered mandate letters would be published. The bill does not itself require them to apply for approval or follow a new review process.
  • People making freedom-of-information requests: The Cabinet-deliberations exemption could not be used to refuse a mandate letter. The bill does not say that other possible grounds for withholding information are removed.
  • Current law: The supplied explanatory note says the existing Act contains a Cabinet-deliberations exemption. The parent Acts were not supplied, so the full current rules and any other relevant exemptions could not be checked.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require the Premier to ensure publication on a government website, but gives no estimate of staffing, website or other costs.
  • It sets no fee, fine, tax or direct benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set a penalty or other specific consequence if a letter is not published on time.
  • It does not explain how “as soon as possible” would be applied within the one-week limit.
  • It does not state whether or when information in a letter could be withheld under other disclosure exemptions.
  • It gives no detailed process for checking whether a communication meets the definition of a mandate letter.
  • It specifies that the Act would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not say whether it received Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let the public see what work and policy objectives the Premier has assigned to Cabinet members and Parliamentary Assistants.
  • Requiring publication within a set deadline would make access less dependent on someone filing a freedom-of-information request.
  • Preventing reliance on the Cabinet-deliberations exemption for these letters could make their contents more accessible even when they reveal Cabinet deliberations.
  • Publishing letters dating back to June 7, 2018 would provide access to qualifying past letters as well as new ones.

Case against#

  • One concern is that requiring publication of letters that may reveal Cabinet deliberations limits the use of an existing confidentiality exemption for this category of records.
  • The bill does not explain how this rule interacts with other grounds for withholding information, which could leave uncertainty about what a requester would receive.
  • The one-week deadline and the duty to publish older letters require government work, but the bill gives no cost estimate or detailed compliance process.