Summary#
Bill 127, the Captain Craig Bowman Act, 2023, would amend Ontario’s Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, 1997. Its stated change is to shorten the service or employment period needed for a presumption that primary-site esophageal cancer is work-related to apply.
- For full-time and part-time firefighters and fire investigators, the threshold would be at least 20 years of employment before diagnosis.
- For volunteer firefighters, the threshold would be at least 20 years of service before diagnosis.
- The presumption means the disease is treated as an occupational disease caused by the nature of the work, unless the contrary is shown. Any other prescribed conditions and restrictions would still apply.
- The bill also changes when the Act’s claims-based-on-presumptions section applies, to include cases where this new threshold makes the presumption apply. The supplied text does not show the rest of that section.
What it means for you#
- Firefighters and fire investigators: If you have primary-site esophageal cancer and meet the 20-year threshold, the presumption could apply to your claim, subject to other prescribed conditions and restrictions. The bill does not guarantee compensation or set a benefit amount.
- Volunteer firefighters: The same 20-year threshold would apply to length of service.
- Other workers: The change is limited to primary-site esophageal cancer among the named firefighting groups. It does not change the presumption for other diseases.
- People with claims: The bill makes the claims section apply when this change causes the presumption to apply. The practical effect depends on provisions of that section not included in the supplied material.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill provides no estimate of any added claim costs, savings, or administrative costs.
- It does not set a fee, fine, or new funding amount.
What is unclear#
- The parent Act and related regulations were not supplied, so the full claims process and all other eligibility rules could not be checked against current law.
- The bill does not explain how the changed claims-section rule affects claims already made or decided.
- The bill does not give a start date beyond saying it comes into force on Royal Assent; no Royal Assent date is provided.
- No publicly available information in the supplied material gives a cost estimate or explains how any added costs would be paid.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that a 20-year threshold would let the presumption apply to qualifying workers with fewer years of service than the current 25-year requirement described in the explanatory note.
- The presumption can matter because it treats the disease as work-related unless the contrary is shown, rather than requiring the worker to establish that link in the usual way.
- The bill keeps the presumption limited to named firefighting roles and primary-site esophageal cancer.
Case against#
- One concern is that lowering the threshold could lead to more claims receiving the presumption, but the bill gives no estimate of the number of claims or resulting costs.
- The bill does not explain how the revised claims-section rule would affect claims already in progress or previously decided.
- The presumption remains subject to other prescribed conditions and restrictions, but those are not set out in the supplied bill text.