Housing zoning bill pushes midrise on major streets

Summary#

Bill 156 would amend Ontario’s Planning Act. The bill text gives it the short title Homes You Can Afford in the Communities You Love Act, 2023; the supplied bill listing says 2024. Its title signals a goal of supporting housing affordability, but the bill does not guarantee that homes will be built or affordable.

  • Municipal official plans would have to authorize up to four residential units in detached houses, semi-detached houses and rowhouses, and multi-unit residential buildings up to four storeys, in areas of settlement.
  • Official plans would also have to authorize six- to 11-storey midrise housing on major streets, including transit corridors, where sewage and water capacity is sufficient. A “major street” is defined as a highway whose primary function is not providing access to properties.
  • Local municipal councils would have to ensure their zoning by-laws give effect to both sets of policies.
  • Appeals would not be allowed on these policies or the related parts of zoning by-laws, including their requirements or standards. The Minister could still appeal.
  • The Minister could make regulations requiring municipalities to prepare servicing plans to ensure enough sewage and water capacity for midrise housing on all major streets, within a timeframe set by regulation.

What it means for you#

  • Municipalities: Councils would have to bring zoning by-laws into line with the required official-plan policies. The bill does not itself set a deadline for this work.
  • Property owners and builders: The policies would allow the specified housing types in areas of settlement, subject to the required local by-laws and applicable standards. The bill does not require anyone to build, or automatically grant a building permit.
  • Residents and other parties: You could not appeal the specified official-plan policies or the related parts of zoning by-laws. The Minister would retain an appeal right. The bill does not remove other appeal rights generally.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Municipalities would have to update or ensure their zoning by-laws give effect to the policies. No staffing or cost estimate is provided.
  • The Minister could require servicing plans by regulation. The bill does not say how much preparing those plans or providing sewage and water capacity would cost.
  • The bill does not set a tax, fee, fine, benefit or direct funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current Planning Act, so the existing rules and the full extent of the change could not be verified.
  • The bill does not set a deadline for municipalities to update their by-laws. For servicing plans, a deadline would be set only if the Minister makes a regulation.
  • It does not explain how “sufficient” sewage and water capacity would be assessed, or what happens if capacity is not sufficient.
  • The bill does not specify how the required standards would be set or how the policies would interact with other planning rules.
  • The bill text gives the short title as 2023, while the supplied bill listing says 2024.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that requiring plans and zoning by-laws to allow more homes could remove local rules that prevent these housing forms.
  • Allowing additional units in existing house types and midrise buildings on major streets could create more opportunities for housing within settlement areas.
  • Limiting appeals on these policies and related by-law parts could reduce delays in putting them into effect, while preserving the Minister’s right to appeal.
  • The sewage and water capacity condition recognizes that midrise housing depends on adequate servicing.

Case against#

  • Removing appeal rights for the specified policies and related by-law parts would limit the ability of residents and other parties to challenge them; only the Minister’s appeal is preserved under these provisions.
  • The bill requires municipalities to change their by-laws but provides no funding or estimate for that work.
  • The servicing condition may limit where midrise housing is authorized, but the bill does not explain how capacity will be measured or when it must be addressed.
  • The bill sets rules for what plans must authorize; it does not ensure that housing is built or affordable.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2024022202

    Passed80 members voted

    Trevor Jones moved, That, pursuant to Standing Order 77(a), the Order for Second Reading of Bill 156

    FOR · 62AGAINST · 18

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    62For

    • PC61
    • Independent1

    18Against

    • NDP9
    • Liberal7
    • Green2