Bill would require midrise housing on major streets

Summary#

Bill 45, the Building More Homes on Major Streets and Transit Corridors Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Planning Act. It would require official plans and local zoning by-laws to allow for certain midrise developments; its stated goal is to make room for this housing on major streets, including transit corridors.

  • Official plans would have to authorize buildings from six to 11 storeys in settlement areas on major streets. The bill defines a major street as a highway whose primary function is not providing access to properties.
  • Local municipal councils would have to ensure their zoning by-laws give effect to those policies.
  • Appeals would generally not be allowed against these policies, their requirements or standards, or the parts of zoning by-laws that give effect to them. The Minister could still appeal.
  • The bill also adds amending or revoking these policies to a list in section 22 of the Planning Act. The supplied text does not include enough surrounding text to explain the full effect of that change.

The Planning Act itself was not supplied, so I could not verify how these changes would interact with current law. The bill says it would take effect on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Municipalities: Councils would have to make official plan policies and zoning by-laws consistent with the required authorization for six-to-11-storey development in the stated locations.
  • People who own or want to develop property on a major street: The bill would require planning rules to authorize this type of development, but it does not automatically approve a particular project or require anyone to build.
  • People affected by planning decisions: Appeals about the specified policies and by-law provisions would generally be barred, but the Minister’s appeal right would remain. The bill does not remove appeals about every planning issue.
  • Residents generally: The bill does not itself build homes, set rents, change taxes or create a new housing benefit.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Municipal councils would have a duty to make their zoning by-laws give effect to the policies, but the bill gives no estimate of the staffing or other costs.
  • The bill does not state a new tax, fee, fine, appropriation or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say which streets qualify as major streets beyond its definition, or how municipalities must identify them.
  • It does not set out what requirements or standards the policies must include, or how competing planning rules would apply.
  • It does not create application, review, approval, timeline or reporting rules for individual developments.
  • The supplied text does not explain the full effect of adding the policy changes to section 22 of the Planning Act.
  • The bill’s current status is not given. No publicly available information.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would require municipalities to allow midrise housing in specified locations, rather than leaving that choice entirely to local policy.
  • Requiring zoning by-laws to give effect to the policies could make the planning rules consistent with the official plans.
  • Limiting appeals on these specific policies and by-law provisions could reduce the chance that the required rules are blocked through those appeals.

Case against#

  • One concern is that restricting appeals would limit the ability of people and other parties to challenge these particular policies or related by-law provisions; the Minister would retain an appeal right.
  • The bill does not spell out the standards or local process for applying the requirement, leaving important implementation details unanswered.
  • Municipalities would have to change their planning rules, but the bill provides no cost estimate or funding.
  • The bill requires planning rules to authorize the stated building heights, but does not ensure that any homes will be built.