Home Warranties Overhaul Increases Protections

Summary#

Bill 169, the Home Warranties to Protect Families Act, 2019, would amend the Ontario New Home Warranties Plan Act, rename it the New Home Buyer Protection Act, and repeal two other 2017 Acts. Its stated goal is to replace the existing single-provider warranty system with a multi-provider system; the supplied explanatory note identifies Tarion as the current sole provider, but the parent Act was not supplied to verify current law.

  • Vendors could not sell or offer to sell a new home, and builders could not start building one, unless it is covered by a policy from an eligible warranty provider.
  • Each policy would have to include minimum warranties: workmanlike construction, fitness for habitation and compliance with the Ontario Building Code; at least two years for defects in materials and labour, five years for building-envelope defects, and 10 years for major structural defects. Regulations could set exclusions and limits.
  • The Minister must appoint an administrator to take control of Tarion Corporation, oversee the transition and take over builder and vendor registration duties. The administrator gets the board’s, officers’ and members’ powers and duties, subject to the Act and any Minister’s directions.
  • Within six months of that appointment, the government must establish a transition agency to manage the existing guarantee fund and claims under old Plan warranties until those warranties expire. The Agency could also qualify as a warranty provider.
  • The Registrar must publish builders’ and vendors’ warranty claims and relevant past conduct online. A Minister-appointed Director would take on administration and enforcement powers assigned under the Act.
  • If regulations provide for it, renovations or sales of renovated homes would also require a warranty policy. The bill would allow regulations on mediation or arbitration of disputes.

What it means for you#

  • Homebuyers and owners: A new-home policy would have to provide the listed minimum warranties. The warranties would benefit whoever owns the home during the warranty period, even without a direct contract with the vendor. Some buyers who do not get possession, and some landowners whose builder fails to substantially perform, would also qualify for warranty payments, subject to regulations.
  • People with an existing Plan warranty: The transition Agency would take over responsibility for those warranties and related claims. The bill does not end them when the system changes.
  • Builders and vendors: They would need an eligible provider’s coverage before starting construction or offering a new home for sale. Vendors would have to give the buyer a copy of the policy and required documents; at completion, they would have to provide a certificate with the completion date and warranty start date.
  • Warranty providers: Insurers licensed under the Insurance Act to offer these warranties, and other people with qualifications set by regulation, could provide them. The bill does not itself specify those other qualifications.
  • General public: The bill does not set a new tax, create a direct payment to homebuyers, or guarantee that competition will lower warranty costs.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The administrator must be a provincial public servant. The Agency may hire or otherwise engage staff; the bill gives no staffing numbers or cost estimate.
  • The Agency would pay eligible claims from the existing guarantee fund for old Plan warranties. The bill gives no fund balance or total expected claims.
  • The administrator must pay former board members any compensation or severance required by regulations; the amounts are not stated.
  • The bill does not set new fees or fines.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not specify the qualifications that non-insurer warranty providers must hold, or how providers would be approved and monitored.
  • Regulations would set important details, including warranty exclusions, limits, payment amounts, and what counts as a major structural defect.
  • The bill does not set out a claims process, decision deadlines, or appeal rules for disputes involving the new policies. It allows regulations on mediation or arbitration.
  • It is unclear how the Agency’s legacy role would overlap with its ability to become a warranty provider.
  • The start date for the main system changes depends on a proclamation; the bill does not give that date. The parent Act and the two repealed Acts were not supplied, so their current rules and the full effect of repeal could not be checked.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to end reliance on one warranty provider and allow more providers to compete.
  • A policy with minimum legal guarantees could protect owners even when a sale contract does not provide the same protections.
  • Publishing warranty claims and relevant past conduct could give buyers information about builders and vendors.
  • Keeping a separate Agency responsible for old warranties could allow existing claims to continue while the new system is introduced.

Case against#

  • Competition alone does not ensure that policies will be affordable or that claims will be handled well; the bill leaves key provider and policy rules to regulations.
  • The administrator would have broad control over the Corporation, while the Minister could direct the administrator. The bill does not set out detailed oversight or public reporting requirements.
  • The Agency could both manage old claims and, if qualified, provide new warranties. The bill does not explain how that overlap would be managed.
  • The transition requires public staff and Agency operations, but the bill provides no cost estimate or funding plan.