Transit assets tied to affordable housing

Summary#

Bill 184, the Supporting Mobility, Affordability and Reliable Transportation in Ontario Act, 2024, would amend the Metrolinx Act, 2006, the Public Transportation and Highway Improvement Act and the Shortline Railways Act, 1995. Its stated goal is to support transportation, affordability and mobility; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result.

  • Metrolinx would have a new object: promoting and facilitating the integration of routes, fares and schedules of municipal bike share systems.
  • When Metrolinx or a subsidiary sells or otherwise disposes of assets to build residential units, it must ensure at least 20% of those units are affordable, as defined in the Development Charges Act, 1997.
  • The Minister must ensure Highways 11, 17 and 69 meet specific snow, ice and pothole maintenance standards, including on two-lane portions.
  • A shortline railway company proposing to stop operating a line must advertise and notify the registrar, give interested parties a chance to make offers, and negotiate in good faith.
  • If no transfer is completed through that process, the company must offer the line to Ontario and affected municipalities for its net salvage value. If no transfer follows, the company may discontinue operations and dispose of connected assets.

What it means for you#

  • Bike share users: The bill gives Metrolinx a role in promoting and facilitating coordination between municipal bike share systems and regional transit. It does not require a particular fare system, route connection or schedule.
  • People seeking affordable housing: The 20% requirement applies when a Metrolinx entity sells or disposes of assets for the purpose of building housing. It is not a general requirement for all housing projects.
  • Drivers on Highways 11, 17 and 69: The bill sets deadlines for clearing snow and ice and repairing certain large potholes. It does not set these standards for other highways.
  • Shortline railway companies and potential operators: Companies must follow the notice, offer and negotiation process before discontinuing a line. Interested parties must make their interest known by the date in the advertisement, which must be at least 30 days after its first publication.
  • Ontario and affected municipalities: They would have a chance to accept an offer to buy, lease or otherwise take over a line for its net salvage value. Ontario has priority; if it does not accept in time, municipalities have priority based on when they accept.
  • Current law: The supplied material says the shortline process was repealed in 2019 and would be re-enacted. The parent Acts were not supplied, so current law and the full effect of the amendments could not be verified.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s total public cost is included in the supplied material.

  • Metrolinx and the Ministry would have new responsibilities, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Ontario or a municipality that accepts a railway offer would pay the net salvage value; the bill does not estimate that amount.
  • If the parties cannot agree on net salvage value and use an independent appraiser, they share the appraiser’s cost equally. Arbitration may be used if they cannot agree on an appraiser or arbitration terms.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how bike share routes, fares or schedules would be integrated, or require Metrolinx to achieve a particular level of integration.
  • The affordable-housing definition is incorporated from another Act, which was not supplied. The bill does not set out how affordability would be measured or enforced.
  • For highway standards, the bill does not say who must become aware of ice or potholes, or what happens if a deadline is missed.
  • The bill does not set detailed rules for assessing railway offers or resolving disputes over whether an agreement has been completed.
  • The material does not state the bill’s current status. Most provisions would start on Royal Assent; the housing provision would start later, on the later of Royal Assent and the start of a specified provision of the More Homes Built Faster Act, 2022.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that better coordination between transit and bike share could make it easier to connect different ways of travelling.
  • Requiring affordable units in housing built after a Metrolinx asset sale could link the use of public transportation assets to an affordability condition.
  • Clear maintenance deadlines could set concrete expectations for snow, ice and serious potholes on the three named highways.
  • The railway process gives potential operators and public bodies a chance to take over a line before the company can discontinue service and dispose of its assets.

Case against#

  • The bill sets duties and deadlines without stating the staffing, funding or enforcement arrangements needed to meet them.
  • The affordable-housing rule covers only specified Metrolinx asset sales or dispositions. The bill does not explain how the 20% requirement would work in practice.
  • The highway deadlines may be difficult to meet, and the bill does not explain what consequences follow if they are missed.
  • The railway process could leave key decisions—such as how offers are evaluated and how net salvage value is assessed—to later agreements or dispute processes.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2024042501

    Defeated88 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 184

    AGAINST · 61FOR · 27

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    61Against

    • PC59
    • Independent2

    27For

    • NDP20
    • Liberal6
    • Green1