Bill would form child care worker commission

Summary#

Bill 49 would create a new law, the Early Years and Child Care Worker Advisory Commission Act, 2022. It would establish a commission to recommend ways to support the early years and child care workforce and address staffing shortages; that is the bill’s stated goal, not a guaranteed result.

  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council would appoint commission members from the workforce, organizations that represent it, labour unions that represent it, and early years and child care experts.
  • Appointments must ensure, to the extent possible, that Black, Indigenous and other racialized communities are represented.
  • The commission must make recommendations on wages, salary scales based on skill and experience, minimum work standards, and ways for workers to advance their qualifications.
  • The commission must publish an annual report on a Government of Ontario website and send it to the Minister of Education. The Minister must meet with the commission each year to discuss its reports.
  • The bill does not require the government or employers to adopt the recommendations or change pay or working conditions.

What it means for you#

  • Early years and child care workers and their representative groups: Some members would be appointed from these groups. The bill does not set out how people are selected or provide a way to apply.
  • Workers: The commission must consider recommendations on wages, salary scales, benefits, paid sick leave, paid planning and professional-development time, and qualification advancement. The bill itself does not create these pay or work standards.
  • Minister of Education: The Minister must meet with the commission annually to discuss its reports. The bill does not require the Minister to accept or act on its recommendations.
  • Families, employers and the public: The bill does not directly change child care services, fees, eligibility, or staffing requirements. The commission’s annual recommendations would be public.
  • Indigenous, Black and other racialized communities: Their representation must be ensured “to the extent possible,” but the bill does not specify a minimum number of members or how representation is to be achieved.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill creates a commission and requires annual reports and meetings, but gives no cost estimate or funding amount.
  • It does not say whether members would be paid, who would provide staff or other support, or how those costs would be covered.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not specify the commission’s size, members’ terms, appointment process, or whether members would be paid.
  • It does not set out how the commission would gather information or decide on its recommendations.
  • It does not define “minimum work standards” or explain whether the commission would consult workers, employers, families, or communities.
  • It does not require the Minister to respond publicly to the recommendations or explain whether they will be considered in government decisions.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a standing commission could give workers, their representative organizations and experts a regular way to develop advice on staffing shortages.
  • Annual public reports could make recommendations on wages, benefits and working conditions visible.
  • Requiring the Minister to meet with the commission could create a regular opportunity to discuss those recommendations.

Case against#

  • The commission is advisory: the bill does not require the government or employers to adopt its recommendations.
  • The bill does not require the Minister to respond to the reports, so the effect of the annual meeting is unclear.
  • The bill leaves important practical details, including membership size and resources, unsettled; these could affect how much work the commission can do.
  • Representation of Black, Indigenous and other racialized communities is qualified by “to the extent possible,” with no minimum representation set.