Homebuyer Protections Expanded for New Homes

Summary#

Bill 200, the Homeowner Protection Act, 2024, is an enacted law that amends five Ontario Acts. Its stated goals include protecting homeowners and giving new-home buyers time to review purchase information; those are goals, not guaranteed results.

  • New-home sales: Once the relevant provisions are in force, vendors must give buyers of new freehold homes and other prescribed new homes required information. The agreement will not bind the buyer until the information and any related requirements are met. Buyers will have a limited right to cancel and get a refund with interest.
  • Consumer-goods security notices: Notices of security interests in consumer goods registered on land titles generally expired when the Act received Royal Assent. Regulations may allow notices for prescribed goods.
  • Heritage properties: The deadline for removing certain undesignated properties from municipal heritage registers moves from January 1, 2025 to January 1, 2027, or a later prescribed date. New rules also limit when some removed properties can be listed again.
  • Transit-oriented community land: The Planning Act limits on remedies do not apply, and are treated as never having applied, to land designated as transit-oriented community land.
  • Public documents: The law allows regulations or by-laws to require the new-home regulatory authority and the Ontario New Home Warranties Plan Corporation to make specified documents public. It does not itself require every document to be published.

What it means for you#

  • New-home buyers: When the relevant provisions start, you will get a right to cancel a covered purchase agreement by giving written notice within 10 days after the latest of receiving the required information, meeting any related requirements, and receiving the agreement signed by both sides. You must cancel before accepting a deed in registerable form. The vendor must promptly refund money credited toward the purchase price, with interest at a prescribed rate and without a penalty or charge.
  • New-home vendors and builders: Purchase agreements and construction contracts, and their parties, must meet requirements that may be set by regulation. Vendors of covered homes must deliver the prescribed information and meet related requirements.
  • Homeowners with consumer-goods security notices on title: Notices in effect immediately before Royal Assent were deemed expired and cannot be extended. The law allows expired notices to be deleted from title. Regulations may provide an exception for prescribed consumer goods.
  • Municipalities and property owners: Municipal councils face longer deadlines for removing certain undesignated properties from heritage registers, and limits on relisting some properties for five years after removal. The rules vary by when and why a property was removed.
  • People with interests involving transit-oriented community land: The Act removes the specified Planning Act limits on remedies for land designated under the Transit-Oriented Communities Act. The materials do not explain how this affects any particular claim.
  • People bringing claims against Ontario over the security-notice changes: The law bars many claims and remedies against the Crown and specified current or former officials and employees connected to those changes. Judicial review is not barred, but other proceedings seeking remedies are generally barred.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the available material.

  • Vendors must pay covered buyers a refund with interest if the buyer properly cancels; the interest rate is to be prescribed.
  • No publicly available information on government, municipal, business or consumer costs, or on the financial effects of the changes to claims and remedies.

What is unclear#

  • The new-home provisions requiring information and setting agreement requirements need regulations. The supplied material does not give the required information, any exemptions, or the prescribed interest rate.
  • The new-home provisions covering purchase agreements and buyer cancellation come into force on a date set by proclamation. No proclamation date is given in the supplied material.
  • The goods, if any, that regulations may exempt from the general restriction on consumer-goods notices are not specified here.
  • The supplied material does not explain how the heritage-register rules interact with every existing municipal process, or how the change to remedies will affect specific transit-oriented community lands or claims.
  • The full current versions of the amended Acts were not supplied, so changes beyond those described in the bill and explanatory note could not be checked against current law.

Case for#

  • The new-home provisions appear intended to give buyers required information before an agreement binds them and time to reconsider a major purchase.
  • Requiring refunds with interest after a valid cancellation could reduce the financial penalty of using that right.
  • Ending many land-title notices for consumer goods could address the bill’s stated concern about misuse of those registrations.
  • Extra time for heritage-register deadlines could give municipalities more time before certain properties must be removed.

Case against#

  • Key protections for homebuyers depend on future regulations and a proclamation date. The bill itself leaves important details unsettled.
  • The five-year limits on relisting some heritage properties could restrict municipal councils’ ability to put them back on a register.
  • The broad, retrospective limits on claims against the Crown over the security-notice changes could leave affected people with fewer ways to seek compensation or other remedies.
  • The change to remedies for transit-oriented community land is broad in wording; the supplied material does not explain its effect on particular claims.