Summary#
Bill 236, the Captive Wildlife Protection Act, 2024, would create a new Ontario law and amend the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act, 1997. Its stated goal is to protect captive wildlife by requiring zoos to be licensed and setting rules for their operation.
- The Minister would appoint separate people as Director and Registrar. The Registrar would issue and renew zoo licences, and could set licence conditions. A licence could not be transferred.
- A zoo would need a licence to establish, operate or maintain it. A licence application would need animal records, staff qualifications, a site plan and an emergency plan, among other information.
- A zoo would have to meet standards of care set later by regulation, carry liability insurance in an amount set by regulation, and meet other licensing tests. These include not keeping wild animals for entertainment.
- The Chief Animal Welfare Inspector would have to arrange annual inspections of licensed zoos. Inspectors could order a licensee to fix a contravention. The Chief Inspector could also remove an animal from an unlicensed zoo and take possession of it for the Minister.
- The bill would restrict acquiring, possessing, trading, breeding or using wild animals without a zoo licence, unless the animal and activity are prescribed by regulation. It sets maximum fines of $50,000 for an individual and $250,000 for a corporation for specified offences.
- Existing zoos could operate without a licence for one year after the Act starts, subject to any conditions the Minister imposes. A person who already owns a wild animal and is not a zoo could keep it until it dies, but could not breed it or use it for entertainment; they would have to register it and allow annual inspections.
What it means for you#
- Zoo operators: You would need a licence and would face annual inspections. The law defines a zoo broadly as an establishment where a wild animal is kept for any purpose, including exhibition, education or entertainment.
- People who keep wild animals outside a zoo: The bill would generally bar acquiring, possessing, trading, breeding or using a wild animal without a zoo licence, subject to future regulations. Existing owners would get the limited transition described above.
- Taxpayers and the public: The Director would have to report each year on zoos, animal inventories, inspections, orders and outstanding public health, safety or animal welfare concerns. The bill does not create a new independent agency.
Money#
The bill requires appointments and annual inspections, but no cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- Licence fees and the required amount of liability insurance would be set later by regulation.
- The bill does not state how many staff or how much funding would be needed for licensing, inspections or enforcement.
What is unclear#
- Regulations would set standards of care, staff qualifications, fees, insurance amounts, conservation requirements and any exceptions for prescribed species and activities. Those rules are not in the bill.
- The bill does not set a deadline for deciding licence applications or explain how inspections would be scheduled beyond requiring them annually.
- Several key decisions are left to the Registrar, including whether an applicant has enough financial resources and whether a licence would be contrary to the public interest. The bill does not define those tests.
- The Registrar may suspend a licence immediately without first proposing the suspension if considered necessary in the public interest. The licensee can request a hearing, but the bill does not explain what happens to the suspension after the order expires.
- The supplied material does not include the Provincial Animal Welfare Services Act, 2019 or the current text of the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act, 1997. I could not verify how the bill’s cross-references compare with current inspection, removal or licensing rules.
Case for#
- A licensing system could make operators provide animal inventories, emergency plans, staff qualifications and proof of insurance before operating.
- Annual inspections and orders to fix contraventions could provide regular checks on animal care and public safety.
- The bill allows animals to be removed from unlicensed zoos, adding a way to respond when animals are held outside the licensing system.
- Regulations could set detailed care standards and conservation requirements that apply to zoos.
Case against#
- The bill leaves many important requirements to future regulations, so operators and the public cannot yet know the full standards, fees or exceptions.
- The broad definitions of “zoo” and “entertainment” could bring a range of settings and activities within the rules. The bill does not explain how those terms will be applied in borderline cases.
- The Registrar has broad discretion over licence conditions and eligibility, while an immediate suspension can take effect before a hearing.
- The bill requires new appointments and inspections but gives no cost estimate or staffing plan.