Summary#
Bill 23, the Zebra Mussel Assessment Act, 2018, would create a new Act. It would require the Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks, using the provisions of the Ontario Water Resources Act, to direct an investigation into the extent of the zebra mussel problem in a listed group of waterways. Its stated goal is to determine zebra mussel content in those waterways.
- The duty applies to Greer Creek, Greer Lake, Greers Bay, Greggio Lake, Greggs Lake, Gregory Bay, Gregory Creek, Gregory Lake, Grehan Lake, Greig Lake, Gremm Lake, Grenadier Creek, Grenadier Lake, Grenadier Pond, Grenfell Lake, Grenier Lake, Grenville Lake, Greske Lake, Greta Lake, Gretchel Creek, Gretchel Lake, Gretel Creek, Gretel Lake, Grew Lake, Grew River, Grey Duck Lake, Grey Lake, Grelava Lake, Grey Owl Bay, Grey Owl Lake, Green Creek, Greengrass Lake, Greenheart Creek, Greenheart Lake, Greenhedge Lake, Greenhill Lake, Greenhill Rapids, Greenhill River, Greenhorn Bay, Greenhue Lake, Greening Lake, Greening’s Bay, Greenish Creek, Greenish Lake, Green Island Bay, Green Island Lake, Green Lake, Green Lakes, Greenland Lake, Greenlaw Lake, Greenleaf Creek, Greenleaf Lake, Greenlee Lake, Greenmantle Lake, Greenmantle River, Greenock Creek, Greenock Lake, Greenough Harbour, Greenpike Lake, Gravel Lake, Gravel Lakes, Gravelly Bay, Gravelpit Lake, Gravel Pit Pond, Gravelridge Lake, Gravel River, Gravenor Lake, Graves Lake, Graveyard Creek and Graveyard Lake.
- The Minister must direct an investigation. The bill does not set out a required method or say that the Minister personally must carry out the investigation.
- The bill does not create a ban, fee, fine, benefit, or right to a particular government service.
What it means for you#
- Minister and ministry: The Minister would have a legal duty to direct an investigation into the extent of the zebra mussel problem in each waterway named in the bill.
- People and organizations using the named waterways: The bill does not directly change access, use, or ownership of those waterways. It does not require users to apply, report, or take action.
- Other waterways: They are not included in this bill’s list.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill assigns a duty to the Minister but gives no estimate for the investigation, staffing, or other costs.
- It does not specify a funding source or authorize a stated amount of spending.
What is unclear#
- The Ontario Water Resources Act is not supplied, so the existing duties and powers in subsection 15(1), and how this bill would work with current law, could not be verified.
- The bill gives no deadline, investigation method, or requirement to publish findings.
- It does not say what “extent of the zebra mussel problem” means or what action, if any, should follow the investigation.
- It does not explain how the work would be funded or who would carry it out.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to obtain information about zebra mussels in the waterways it names.
- Requiring the Minister to direct investigations could give the government a clearer basis for deciding whether further action is needed.
- Naming the waterways makes the scope of the required investigation specific.
Case against#
- The bill requires an investigation but does not set a deadline, method, or public reporting requirement, so the work and its results may not be easy to assess.
- It does not require any response if the investigation finds a problem.
- The bill does not state the cost or explain how the work would fit with existing duties under the Ontario Water Resources Act.