Summary#
Bill 155, the Agricultural Research Institute of Ontario Amendment Act, 2024, amends the Agricultural Research Institute of Ontario Act. It renames the existing Crown-agent corporation Agricultural Research and Innovation Ontario and changes its governance, powers and financial rules. Its stated goal is to support research and innovation in agriculture and food, and the development and commercialization of related technology.
- The Minister appoints a board of 7 to 15 members. A public servant appointed by the Public Service Commission serves as Managing Director and administers the corporation.
- The corporation’s objects include advising the Minister; establishing and encouraging research and innovation programs; consulting with agriculture and food researchers and industry; building relationships; supporting commercialization; and transferring research knowledge into use.
- The corporation may acquire, own, control, maintain, dispose of or otherwise deal with property. With the Managing Director’s approval, it may make agreements with property owners to conserve, protect or preserve agricultural lands.
- The corporation may deal in intellectual property, subject to the Managing Director’s approval and applicable laws or government directives. It may not create or acquire a subsidiary.
- The corporation must prepare a public annual business plan with key performance measures, submit its budget to the Minister and provide information the Minister requires. Its programs are supervised by the Managing Director.
- The Act allows regulations to authorize fees and other ways to generate revenue. That authority does not itself set a fee.
What it means for you#
- Researchers and agriculture and food organizations: The corporation’s stated work covers research and innovation in agriculture and food, including equipment and technology, veterinary medicine, and rural-community needs related to those sectors. The bill does not require researchers or organizations to apply for funding or take part in a program.
- Property owners: The corporation may enter conservation agreements with owners or holders of interests in real property. The bill does not require an owner to enter such an agreement.
- The corporation and government: The corporation is an agent of the Crown, not a new independent body. The Minister appoints its board and may require information; the Managing Director must supervise its funded programs. Public servants must be appointed to serve as Managing Director and Comptroller.
- People dealing with the corporation: The bill limits some legal claims against government and corporation personnel for actions done in good faith in their duties, and bars certain proceedings involving acts or omissions of others related to duties under the Act. Judicial review remains available. The Crown and corporation remain liable where the bill says they otherwise would be.
- The public: The bill does not itself promise a research grant, set program eligibility rules, or require every research project to be funded.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated cost.
- Public servants must be appointed as Managing Director and Comptroller, and the corporation must arrange annual audits. No staffing or audit cost estimate is provided.
- The corporation must submit a budget to the Minister. It may not spend or incur liabilities outside that budget unless the Managing Director approves.
- Borrowing and financial-risk management require an approved by-law; the Ontario Financing Authority must coordinate and arrange those activities unless the Minister of Finance approves otherwise in writing.
- The corporation’s revenues and assets are kept outside the Consolidated Revenue Fund and must be used for its objects. Regulations may later authorize fees or other revenue measures, but the bill sets no fee.
What is unclear#
- The Act says it starts on a day set by proclamation. The supplied material does not say when that day is.
- The bill does not set program funding, eligibility, application or decision rules, timelines, or appeal rights.
- The bill does not set any fees. Their scope and amount would depend on later regulations.
- The previous Act was not supplied, so the full extent of what is new compared with the law before this amendment could not be verified.
Case for#
- The bill gives the corporation a broad role in connecting research, industry and government, and in helping research knowledge move into use.
- A dedicated corporation could coordinate research programs and relationships across agriculture and food, while the Managing Director must supervise programs the corporation funds.
- Public business plans, performance measures, annual audits and Minister oversight provide some tools for tracking its work.
- The bill permits property and intellectual-property arrangements that may support research and conservation work.
Case against#
- The bill gives the corporation wide powers over research, property and intellectual property, but does not set program eligibility or decision rules. The public business plan must include performance measures, but the bill does not specify what they must measure.
- Fee-setting is left to future regulations, so the bill does not show what the public or organizations might later be charged.
- The bill limits personal liability for good-faith actions and bars some claims connected to others’ acts or omissions. That may make some remedies harder to pursue, even though judicial review remains available and the Crown and corporation retain certain liabilities.
- The bill requires staff appointments and audits but provides no cost estimate or dedicated funding amount.