Summary#
Bill 67, the Labour Relations Amendment Act (Protecting Ontario’s Power Supply), 2018, was enacted as Chapter 18 of Ontario’s 2018 statutes. It amended the Labour Relations Act, 1995 by setting special rules for Ontario Power Generation Inc. (OPG), the Power Workers’ Union (PWU), and the employees in their power workers bargaining unit. The stated goal was to keep OPG’s operations going and resolve the labour dispute through a fair process.
- For the covered employees, the law prohibited strikes; for OPG, it prohibited lock-outs. It also required any strike or lock-out already underway to end when the Act received Royal Assent.
- OPG had to use all reasonable efforts to continue its operations, including operations interrupted by a strike or lock-out. Employees had to return to work without delay, with an exception for health reasons or mutual agreement with OPG.
- The parties were required to appoint a mediator-arbitrator to resolve remaining disputes. If they did not notify the Minister of Labour of their choice on time, the Minister had to appoint one.
- The mediator-arbitrator could choose the dispute-resolution method, had exclusive authority over matters needed to conclude a new collective agreement, and had to make an award within 90 days of appointment unless the time was extended in writing.
- Existing employment terms generally continued until a new agreement took effect. The award could change terms retroactively, and its fees and expenses had to be split equally between OPG and the union.
- The Act set a later repeal of the special provisions by proclamation. The supplied material does not say when that repeal took effect.
What it means for you#
- OPG employees in the covered bargaining unit: The special rules applied to regular, part-time and temporary employees, including construction-field-force technicians and security employees, subject to listed exclusions. They could not strike under those rules and had to return to work if a strike was underway, except for health reasons or mutual agreement with OPG.
- OPG and the PWU: They could continue negotiating, but could not lock out or strike while the special rules applied. They had to share the mediator-arbitrator’s fees and expenses.
- Other electricity workers and unions: The special rules named OPG and the PWU’s defined bargaining unit; they did not apply to employees represented by other bargaining agents.
- Ontario residents: The law aimed to protect continued electricity operations, but does not guarantee that outages would be prevented. It did not directly change electricity rates, taxes, or household benefits.
Money#
No overall public cost estimate is in the supplied material.
- OPG and the PWU had to pay equal shares of the mediator-arbitrator’s fees and expenses.
- The Minister could have to appoint a mediator-arbitrator if the parties did not do so in time. The cost of that work, if any, is not stated.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not establish whether the later repeal of the special provisions has been proclaimed, so it does not confirm their current status.
- The Labour Relations Act, 1995 as it currently stands was not supplied, so current law and any later amendments could not be checked.
- The bill does not set a detailed hearing process beyond requiring the parties to present evidence and make submissions. It leaves the mediator-arbitrator to choose the dispute-resolution method.
- The bill does not give a fixed limit on extensions to the 90-day deadline; the parties and mediator-arbitrator could agree in writing to extend it.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to avoid a labour disruption at a major electricity generator while a dispute remained unresolved.
- Requiring the parties to use a mediator-arbitrator created a route to a new agreement without a strike or lock-out.
- The process allowed the parties to keep negotiating and to settle the dispute themselves before an award.
- The award criteria included OPG’s ability to pay, Ontario’s economic situation, comparable employees’ terms, and OPG’s ability to attract and retain qualified workers.
Case against#
- The law removed the covered workers’ ability to strike and OPG’s ability to lock them out during the special process, limiting both sides’ bargaining pressure.
- The mediator-arbitrator had exclusive authority over the matters needed for a new agreement, and the law made the appointment and process difficult to challenge in court.
- The bill does not specify the mediator-arbitrator’s method or provide a detailed process for resolving the dispute; those choices were left largely to the mediator-arbitrator.
- The bill requires equal sharing of the mediator-arbitrator’s fees and expenses but gives no estimate of their amount.