Pandemic funding rules set for health

Summary#

Bill 34, the Pandemic Preparedness Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Health Protection and Promotion Act. Its stated goal is to support pandemic preparedness by changing how some public health costs are shared and requiring regular review of Ontario’s pandemic response plan. The bill says it would start on Royal Assent; the available material does not say whether it has received Royal Assent.

  • For cost-shared public health unit programs and services, municipalities could pay no more than 25% of total funding, and the province would provide the remaining funding, to a minimum of 75%. This rule applies only if the Legislature appropriates money for it.
  • The Minister of Health would have to establish a Pandemic Preparedness Review Committee. The minister would appoint members from public health experts, pandemic preparedness experts, and community leaders from equity-seeking groups.
  • The committee would review the pandemic response plan every five years, considering public health practice, medical science and technology, and equity.
  • After each review, the committee would report to the minister. Within 90 days, the minister would have to inform the Legislative Assembly of the findings and make recommendations for the government to implement. The bill does not require the government to adopt them.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set committee members’ pay and expenses, but only if the Legislature appropriates money for that purpose.

What it means for you#

  • Municipalities: If the funding provision applies, they could not be required to fund more than 25% of the total cost of a cost-shared public health unit program or service. The rule would not apply unless money was appropriated.
  • Ontario taxpayers: The province would be responsible for at least 75% of the funding covered by that rule, if the required money is appropriated. The bill does not set a tax or fee.
  • Public health services and the public: The bill changes funding rules and creates a review committee. It does not itself require new front-line services or specify changes to the pandemic response plan.
  • The government: The minister would have to establish the committee and report its findings to the Legislative Assembly with recommendations. The government would not be required by this bill to carry out those recommendations.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill would shift the required shares of covered public health unit funding toward the province, but only if the Legislature appropriates money.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set committee pay and expenses; the bill gives no amount, and payment under that provision also depends on an appropriation.
  • The bill does not state how many committee members there would be or how much the committee would cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define which programs and services count as “cost-shared,” or how the total funding for them would be calculated.
  • The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so the current funding rules and how the new provisions would interact with existing law could not be verified.
  • The bill does not set committee size, appointment criteria, or a process for choosing members. It also does not define “equity-seeking groups.”
  • The committee must report to the minister, but the bill does not require the committee’s full report to be made public.
  • The bill does not require the government to implement committee recommendations.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a provincial minimum share could limit municipalities’ responsibility for the covered public health costs.
  • Regular reviews could give Ontario a recurring chance to consider changes in public health practice and medical science and technology.
  • Requiring the committee to consider equity and include community leaders from equity-seeking groups could bring those perspectives into its review.

Case against#

  • The funding rule depends on money being appropriated, so the bill does not by itself guarantee that the province will provide the required funding.
  • The committee can recommend changes, but the government is not required to adopt them. The bill does not explain how recommendations would be followed up.
  • The minister appoints committee members, while the bill gives no selection criteria, committee size, or public-reporting requirement.
  • The bill provides no cost estimate, and the amount of provincial funding needed is unclear.