Summary#
Bill 24, the Ministry of Community and Social Services Amendment Act (Social Assistance Research Commission), 2018, would amend the Ministry of Community and Social Services Act. Its stated goal is to establish a commission that recommends social assistance rates and policy; it would advise the Minister, not set rates itself.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council would have to establish a nine-member commission, with required expertise and members who receive or recently received Ontario Works or disability support.
- The commission would have to define regions based on economic geography and living costs, then recommend social assistance rates for each region every year.
- Its rate recommendations would have to consider basic necessities, extra costs related to disability, long-term barriers to employment, and other statutory benefits recipients can receive.
- The commission would also recommend policy on social assistance and precarious work, child support, and workplace injury benefits. The Minister could direct it to report on living standards.
- The Minister would have to publish its reports within 30 days and publish a written response to its annual report’s recommendations within 60 days. The bill does not require the Minister to accept or implement them.
What it means for you#
- People receiving or applying for social assistance: The commission would recommend rates, but the bill would not itself change benefit amounts, eligibility, or how benefits are calculated.
- People with disabilities and people who have received Ontario Works: The commission would have to include members with specified expertise, including people receiving or recently receiving these supports. Recent receipt means within the 10 years before appointment.
- Government: The Lieutenant Governor in Council would appoint nine members. The Minister would appoint the chair, receive the commission’s recommendations, publish its reports, and respond to its annual recommendations.
- General public: The commission’s reports and the Minister’s written response would be public. The bill would not create a new independent agency; it would establish an advisory group.
- Current law: The supplied material does not include the existing Ministry of Community and Social Services Act, so what commission-related provisions, if any, already exist could not be checked.
Money#
No publicly available information is provided about the bill’s cost.
- The bill would allow regulations to set members’ terms and remuneration and to provide for retaining experts, but it gives no amounts or budget.
- It does not appropriate a specific sum or change social assistance payments directly.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set a method for measuring costs, choosing regions, or turning the commission’s recommendations into actual benefit rates.
- It does not say how the Minister must respond beyond publishing a written response, or require the Minister to adopt the recommendations.
- Regulations could set important details, including appointments, terms, remuneration, and how experts are retained. Their contents are not provided.
- The bill does not set a commission budget, staffing level, or start date for its work. It says the Act would come into force six months after Royal Assent.
- The supplied material does not say whether the bill passed.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make rate recommendations more regular and tied to regional living costs and a stated list of basic necessities.
- Considering extra disability-related costs and barriers to employment could help the commission account for different circumstances among recipients.
- Requiring relevant expertise and including people who receive or recently received assistance could bring both research knowledge and direct experience into the recommendations.
- Public reports and a required ministerial response would make the recommendations and the government’s response visible.
Case against#
- The commission would recommend rates, but the bill does not require the government to change benefits. Its effect on recipients would depend on decisions outside the commission.
- The bill leaves key methods and operating details to regulations or future decisions, including how regional costs are measured and how the commission is resourced.
- A new commission, appointments, and expert advice could require public spending, but the bill provides no cost estimate.
- The bill requires a written response but does not set standards for that response or require the Minister to explain why recommendations are not adopted.