Summary#
Bill 74’s text gives it the short title Missing Persons Amendment Act, 2023; the supplied bill label says 2024. It amends Ontario’s Missing Persons Act, 2018 to allow requests for a new type of missing-person alert, called a vulnerable persons alert. Its stated goal is to help search for missing people who meet the bill’s definition of a vulnerable person.
- An officer may request an alert if they believe the missing person is a vulnerable person, have descriptive information about that person or someone who may know where they are, and have reasonable grounds to believe the alert will help locate them.
- The definition covers a person who, because of age, disability or other temporary or permanent circumstances, depends on others or faces greater risk than the general population of harm by someone in a position of trust or authority toward them.
- The request may name the Ontario regions where the officer believes the alert would be most effective. The bill does not require a region to be specified.
- The Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) may issue the alert only if it also has authority to issue an AMBER alert.
- The bill adds totals for vulnerable persons alerts requested—and, for the OPP, alerts issued—to the list in an existing reporting provision. The parent Act was not supplied, so who must report and how the information is made public could not be verified.
- The bill says it would come into force on Royal Assent. It does not create a new agency, a guaranteed alert, or a benefit or fine.
What it means for you#
- Missing people and those looking for them: An officer could ask the OPP to issue this alert when the bill’s conditions are met. A request does not mean an alert must be issued.
- People who may be vulnerable: The bill creates a definition for this alert, but does not require officers to request one in every case that fits the definition.
- Police and the OPP: Officers would need to meet the stated conditions to request an alert. The OPP’s authority to issue one is conditional on its authority to issue an AMBER alert.
- General public: The bill does not set out how an alert is sent, how long it stays active, or what information it would contain.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill provides no spending amount, funding source, staffing requirement or estimate of administrative costs.
- The added alert counts may require recordkeeping, but the bill gives no cost estimate.
What is unclear#
- “Other circumstances” and “greater risk” are not further defined in the bill.
- The bill does not explain how the OPP decides whether it has authority to issue an AMBER alert in a particular case.
- It does not set rules for alert content, distribution, duration, cancellation, review or appeal.
- The parent Act was not supplied, so the existing reporting duties and alert rules—and how this proposal would fit with them—could not be checked.
- The bill does not explain how the added alert counts would be reported or whether the public would see them.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to provide an alert option for missing people who may face particular risks because they depend on others or may be harmed by someone in a position of trust or authority.
- Requiring descriptive information and reasonable grounds to believe an alert would help locate the person could limit requests to cases where an alert may assist the search.
- Allowing officers to identify regions where an alert may be most effective could help target the request.
Case against#
- The OPP’s authority to issue the alert depends on its also having authority to issue an AMBER alert. The bill does not explain how that condition will affect cases involving vulnerable people.
- Key terms, including “other circumstances” and “greater risk,” are not defined. This may leave uncertainty about who falls within the alert category.
- The bill adds a possible alert but does not set out how it would be issued, ended or reviewed, or how the public would receive it.