Summary#
Bill 86, the Advisory Committee to Protect Ontario’s People and Economy from Airborne Pandemics Act, 2023, would create a new Act. It would require the Standing Committee on Social Policy to establish an advisory committee on indoor air quality in non-residential workplaces and public settings. The stated goal is to improve Ontario’s infrastructure, rules and standards related to indoor air quality; the bill does not require the government to adopt the committee’s recommendations.
- The Standing Committee on Social Policy must establish the advisory committee within 60 days after the Act comes into force and appoint its members.
- The committee must recommend improvements and examine ventilation, filtration and air cleaning; public education; incentives and subsidies; equitable protection; workplace insurance; protective equipment; rules and data on airborne transmission; and joint health and safety committees’ role in emergencies.
- The committee must consult named health care, engineering, labour, construction, education, child care, business and indoor-air-quality groups, as well as other stakeholders it considers appropriate.
- The committee must report within six months of being established. Within 90 days of receiving its recommendations, the Minister of Health must tell the Assembly which recommendations the Minister and the Standing Committee recommend the government implement. The Minister must report on implementation progress within a year of that statement.
What it means for you#
- People who use or work in public settings: The committee would examine ways to improve indoor air quality in public settings and non-residential workplaces. The bill does not itself change ventilation standards, require air-cleaning upgrades, or create a new service.
- Workers, students, patients and customers: The committee must examine ways to make protective equipment—including N95 respirators—and layered prevention controls available during future pandemics. It must also examine workplace insurance coverage and rules for hazard assessments, infection control, investigations and contact tracing. These are topics for recommendations, not changes the bill makes directly.
- Small businesses and private institutions with public spaces: The committee must examine whether incentives and subsidies should help cover costs of indoor-air improvements. The bill does not create a subsidy or guarantee funding.
- Committee membership: Members must include people with expertise in epidemiology; health care providers experienced with marginalized communities; frontline unionized public education workers; occupational hygienists; small business owners; frontline service-sector workers from public and private unions; engineers, architects, building ventilation and energy-efficiency specialists; indoor-air-quality researchers and aerosol scientists; infectious-disease, medical microbiology and infection-prevention professionals; nurses; health care workers, including personal support workers and developmental services workers; disabled people and their human rights representatives; public-health communications professionals with experience in behaviour change and harm reduction; and other people the Standing Committee considers useful.
- Representation and consultation: The Standing Committee must make all reasonable efforts to include people reflecting the listed diversity of Ontarians exposed to airborne disease: immunocompromised people, seniors, Indigenous people, Black people, other racialized communities, disabled people, people experiencing or who have experienced homelessness, people in close-contact jobs, rural and remote residents, people in long-term care or supportive living, workers in listed care, service and congregate settings, essential workers, and migrant workers or their legal representatives. The advisory committee must also consult the named health care providers and organizations, professional and labour groups, education and child care workers, small business associations, indoor-air-quality groups and Occupational Health Clinics for Ontario Workers.
- Government: The committee is an advisory committee established by a legislative standing committee, not a new independent agency. The Minister must report to the Assembly on selected recommendations and later on implementation progress, but the bill does not require the government to implement them.
Money#
The bill permits remuneration and expenses for committee members, but only if the Legislature appropriates money for that purpose; no cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- The bill does not itself appropriate money or establish incentives, subsidies, or new workplace benefits.
- No information is provided about the committee’s operating costs or any later costs of acting on its recommendations.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set the committee’s size, appointment process, meeting rules, or how it will choose among recommendations.
- It does not explain how the required representation will be assessed, or what counts as an “appropriate combination” of ventilation, filtration and other air-cleaning methods.
- It does not require the government to accept or implement recommendations. It also does not specify how the Minister and Standing Committee will decide which recommendations to recommend for implementation.
- The bill does not set out how any future incentives, subsidies, insurance changes, standards or workplace rules would work or be funded.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to bring technical expertise and the experience of workers and affected communities into recommendations on indoor air quality.
- A single committee could examine connected issues—including building standards, protective equipment, workplace protections and public information—rather than considering each in isolation.
- Required consultation and efforts to reflect diverse groups could help the committee consider people who may face different risks or barriers.
Case against#
- The bill creates an advisory process, not enforceable air-quality standards or a duty to improve buildings. The government could decide not to implement recommendations.
- The bill sets deadlines for forming the committee and reporting, but does not provide a budget, staffing level or detailed operating rules.
- It requires many kinds of expertise and representation but does not set a committee size or explain how to balance those requirements.