Gas Station Prepayment Rule

Summary#

Bill 88, Protecting Ontarians by Enhancing Gas Station Safety to Prevent Gas and Dash Act, 2023, would amend Ontario’s Occupational Health and Safety Act. Its stated goal is to improve safety for gas-station workers; it does not guarantee that result.

  • In the Greater Toronto Area, and in other municipalities that request the rule and are named in a regulation, employers would have to require customers to pay before pumping gasoline from pumps with prepayment technology.
  • That prepayment requirement would start six months after the law takes effect in a municipality. During its first year there, it would apply only to gasoline sold from 9 p.m. to 6 a.m.; after that, it would apply at all times.
  • Employers would have to post notices on pumps with prepayment technology and provide prescribed safety training to workers involved in selling gasoline at stations with those pumps.
  • Owners would have to ensure any new or replacement gasoline pumps installed after the rule applies at their station have prepayment technology. The bill does not require retrofitting existing pumps.
  • Municipalities outside the Greater Toronto Area could be covered only if they pass a resolution requesting the rule and are listed in a regulation.

What it means for you#

  • Customers: At a covered station, you would have to pay before pumping gasoline from a pump with prepayment technology. During the first year the rule applies in your municipality, this would be required only between 9 p.m. and 6 a.m. The bill’s definition of gasoline excludes aviation fuel, leaded gasoline and propane.
  • Gas-station employers: You would have to require prepayment at qualifying pumps, post the required notices, and provide prescribed safety training to workers involved in selling gasoline. The bill does not set out the training details.
  • Gas-station owners: You would have to ensure new or replacement pumps installed after the rule applies have prepayment technology. The bill does not require you to replace existing pumps that lack it.
  • Workers: Workers involved in selling gasoline at stations with prepayment-technology pumps would have to receive safety training. The bill does not specify the training content or frequency.
  • Municipalities: Outside the Greater Toronto Area, a municipality’s resolution alone would not bring the rule into effect; it would also have to be named in a regulation.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change gasoline prices, taxes or fuel eligibility.

Money#

No publicly available information gives an estimate of the bill’s costs.

  • Employers would have to provide training and post notices; owners may face costs when installing new or replacement pumps. The bill gives no amounts.
  • The bill does not set out public funding or a budget for these duties.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the current Occupational Health and Safety Act, so current rules and enforcement powers could not be checked against the proposed changes.
  • Regulations would set notice and training requirements, including when and how often training must happen. Those details are not in the bill.
  • The bill does not say how municipalities would be prescribed or how long that process would take.
  • The bill gives the Lieutenant Governor in Council power to make transitional rules, including requiring notices before the main requirements start. Those rules are not provided.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to reduce gas-and-dash incidents and improve worker safety by requiring advance payment at pumps that can prevent pumping before payment.
  • A possible argument for the design is that it focuses on pumps with the technology to enforce prepayment, rather than requiring it at every pump.
  • The staged start gives covered stations six months before the requirements apply, with the prepayment rule limited to overnight sales during the first year.

Case against#

  • The bill does not require existing pumps without prepayment technology to be upgraded. The prepayment rule would therefore not cover gasoline pumped from those machines.
  • The requirements would differ by location: municipalities outside the Greater Toronto Area would be covered only after local action and a regulation.
  • The bill does not set out the training, notice or transition details. Employers and owners may face uncertainty until regulations are made.
  • The bill requires training and pump technology in specified circumstances but provides no cost estimate.