Movable Soccer Goals Safety Bill

Summary#

Bill 99, Garrett’s Legacy Act (Requirements for Movable Soccer Goals), 2024, creates a new Ontario Act; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to set safety requirements for movable soccer goals made available to the public. The Act is enacted, but it starts only on a date set by proclamation; that date is not given in the supplied material.

  • Organizations and other entities that make movable soccer goals available to the public must ensure each goal is on a level surface, securely anchored as regulations require, and meets any other prescribed requirements.
  • Those organizations and entities must also meet any educational, training or other requirements set by regulation.
  • The Minister may appoint inspectors to check compliance. The Minister must create a way for the public to report alleged breaches.
  • Regulations may set requirements for locating, securing and maintaining goals, including signs and stickers, and may set inspectors’ powers and duties.
  • A person who breaches the Act or a prescribed rule can be fined $100 to $500 for a first offence, and $500 to $5,000 for each later offence.

What it means for you#

  • Organizations and entities providing goals for public use: They will have to meet the Act’s safety duties and any additional requirements set by regulation. The Act does not set out how to comply with those additional requirements yet.
  • Members of the public: You must be given a way to complain about an alleged breach once the Act is in force. The Act does not say how complaints will be handled or what action must follow.
  • People using a goal privately: The Act’s duties apply to organizations and entities that make goals available to members of the public. It does not directly set rules for goals used only privately.
  • People or organizations accused of a breach: A court conviction can result in the fines listed above. The supplied text does not explain who would be held personally responsible when an organization is involved.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The Act allows fines after conviction, but does not estimate how much fine revenue may be collected.
  • Organizations may have costs to secure or maintain goals, provide signs or stickers, or meet training requirements set by regulation. No amounts are given.
  • The Act permits the Minister to appoint inspectors, but does not say how many or estimate staffing or inspection costs.

What is unclear#

  • The Act does not give the start date; it depends on a proclamation.
  • The meaning of “movable soccer goal” may be narrowed by criteria set in regulations. Those criteria are not supplied.
  • The exact anchoring, maintenance, signage, training and other requirements depend on regulations not included here.
  • The Act does not set out inspection procedures, complaint-handling steps, timelines, appeals or required follow-up.
  • It is unclear how the rules would apply where more than one organization or person is involved in making a goal available.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to reduce risks from movable goals by requiring safe placement and secure anchoring.
  • A public complaint mechanism could give people a way to report alleged breaches.
  • Regulations could set more detailed safety and inspection rules, including maintenance and signs or stickers.

Case against#

  • The Act leaves key safety details to future regulations, so organizations cannot tell from this text alone exactly what they must do.
  • The Minister may appoint inspectors, but the Act does not specify inspection frequency, procedures or oversight.
  • The offence and fine provisions apply to breaches of the Act and prescribed rules, while the text does not clarify how responsibility is assigned when an organization provides a goal.
  • Organizations may face equipment, maintenance or training costs, but the available material does not estimate them.