Summary#
Bill 180, Garrett’s Legacy Act (Requirements for Movable Soccer Goals), 2017, would create a new Ontario law. Its stated goal is to set safety requirements for movable soccer goals made available to the public. The text says the Act would start on a day set by proclamation.
- Organizations or entities that make a movable soccer goal available to the public would have to place it on a level surface and secure it.
- Goals would have to be secured according to the manufacturer’s instructions. If there are none, outdoor goals must be attached to the ground; indoor goals must be attached to the floor or wall, or secured with weights.
- The Minister could set further requirements by regulation and could appoint inspectors. Inspections would follow rules set by regulation.
- The Minister would have to establish a way for the public to complain about alleged breaches.
- A person who contravenes the duty could face a fine of up to $500 for each day the breach continues, to a maximum of $5,000.
What it means for you#
- Organizations and entities providing goals for public use: They would have to meet the placement and securing requirements. The Act also allows later regulations to add requirements.
- Members of the public: The Minister would have to establish a way to report alleged breaches. The bill does not set out how complaints would be handled or require a particular response.
- Inspectors and government: The Minister could appoint inspectors, but the bill does not require the Minister to do so. The Act says it binds the Crown.
- Private use: The duty described applies to goals made available for use by the public; the bill does not set out a duty for goals kept for private use only.
Money#
No cost estimate or funding information is provided. No publicly available information.
- The Minister must establish a complaint mechanism, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- The Minister may appoint inspectors; the bill does not require appointments or state their number or cost.
- The bill allows fines of up to $500 per day, to a maximum of $5,000 per offence. It does not estimate how often fines might be imposed or how much revenue they might raise.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not give a start date; that would be set by proclamation.
- It does not define what counts as “securely” anchored or secured, apart from referring to manufacturers’ instructions and the stated fallback methods.
- Regulations could add requirements and set inspection rules, but their contents are not in the bill.
- The bill does not explain how the complaint mechanism would work, what response or timing a complainant could expect, or whether inspections would follow complaints.
- It does not explain how responsibility would be assigned if a person contravenes the duty on an organization or entity.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to reduce the risk of movable goals shifting or falling. Requiring goals to be secured could help address that risk.
- Using manufacturers’ instructions as the first guide could account for differences between goal designs.
- The bill sets fallback rules for both outdoor and indoor goals when manufacturers provide no instructions.
- A public complaint mechanism and possible inspections could help bring alleged breaches to the Minister’s attention.
Case against#
- The bill does not define what “securely” means, so organizations may not know what level of securing is sufficient.
- Further requirements and inspection rules are left to future regulations, whose content is not provided.
- The Minister may appoint inspectors but is not required to do so; the bill does not guarantee inspections.
- The complaint mechanism is mandatory, but the bill does not specify how complaints would be assessed or what action would follow.
- The bill creates a duty and possible fines without stating the expected costs of compliance or enforcement.