Driverless rides regulated statewide

Summary#

HB 4085, titled “Relating to autonomous vehicles,” would create new provisions in Oregon’s Vehicle Code and amend ORS 807.020. Its stated goal is to set rules for autonomous vehicles, including paid rides and delivery. The bill failed and is not law.

  • A person could operate an autonomous vehicle with its automated driving system engaged without driving privileges if the vehicle meets safety and legal conditions. A person operating one without an onboard operator for hire would also need authorization from the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT).
  • ODOT would have to authorize for-hire operation if the applicant supplies the listed vehicle information and a first responder plan. That plan must include a fleet support specialist available whenever the vehicle operates.
  • Operators would have to carry existing required financial-responsibility coverage and at least $1 million in combined single-limit third-party liability coverage per occurrence while the system is engaged.
  • ODOT could exempt fully driverless autonomous vehicles from state equipment requirements. Local governments generally could not prohibit autonomous vehicles or networks, or impose rules specific to them; airports could still charge comparable fees and set reasonably equivalent pickup, drop-off, and staging locations.
  • Authorized on-demand networks would have to disclose fares before a ride is arranged and send customers an electronic receipt. They could not provide taxi or street-hail service.

What it means for you#

  • People using autonomous vehicles: The bill would allow operation without a driver’s license or permit when the bill’s safety and legal conditions are met. For a vehicle without an onboard operator, paid transportation would require ODOT authorization.
  • For-hire operators and networks: Operators would need insurance, submit vehicle and operator information, and provide the first responder plan. Networks would have fare-disclosure and receipt duties. The bill does not set a fixed expiry date for authorization; it would remain in effect unless suspended or revoked.
  • Local governments: They could not prohibit autonomous-vehicle operation or impose taxes, fees, permits, or other requirements specific to autonomous vehicles or networks. The bill would also bar local regulation of on-demand networks, subject to the airport exceptions.
  • ODOT and emergency responders: ODOT would make rules, receive applications and required collision reports, and could grant equipment exemptions. First responders would get information on contacting fleet support and handling or towing a vehicle. The bill does not set up a general application or review process for every autonomous vehicle.
  • People involved in a collision: A person operating an autonomous vehicle involved in a collision causing property damage would have to perform the duties in ORS 811.700. The bill exempts the operator from duties in three other cited sections; the supplied material does not include those sections’ text.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s total public cost.

  • For-hire operators would have to employ a fleet support specialist while their autonomous vehicles operate and meet the bill’s insurance requirements.
  • ODOT would have rulemaking and authorization duties, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Local governments could not impose most taxes or fees on on-demand autonomous vehicle networks. Airports could charge fees consistent with those for similar services.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set a start date. It failed, so it does not change current law.
  • The supplied material does not include the current text of the laws the bill would affect or rely on. I could not verify all current requirements or how much of the bill’s wording would change them.
  • ODOT would define automation levels by rule. The bill does not say what those rules would be.
  • The bill does not set a fixed time for ODOT to act on an authorization application, or specify what counts as a “reasonable” period in parts of the suspension process.
  • The bill does not explain how ODOT would assess vehicle safety before authorization. Its suspension process applies when ODOT determines that an authorized vehicle is unsafe and creates a substantial risk of death or has caused a specified severe harm.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to create a statewide path for autonomous vehicles to operate, including for paid transportation, rather than leaving their operation to separate local rules.
  • A possible argument for the safety conditions is that vehicles must meet state and federal requirements and either reach a stopped, lower-risk condition or request human intervention if the system cannot perform the driving task.
  • Requiring insurance and a first responder plan could give people a way to seek compensation and responders a way to handle vehicles without onboard operators.
  • Fare disclosure and receipts could give customers basic information about the price and details of a ride.

Case against#

  • One concern is that statewide limits would remove local governments’ ability to set rules, fees, or taxes specific to autonomous vehicles and networks, even where local conditions may differ.
  • The bill requires ODOT to authorize an applicant that submits the listed information and plan; it does not spell out a general safety review before authorization.
  • Authorizations would not expire unless suspended or revoked. A possible concern is that the bill does not require periodic renewal or routine review.
  • ODOT could waive any state equipment requirement for fully driverless vehicles. The bill does not set criteria for granting those exemptions.