Insurers must pay appraisers directly in motor claims

Summary#

S-3365, titled “Relating to Insurance—Motor Vehicle Appraisal Provision,” would amend Rhode Island’s existing Motor Vehicle Appraisal Provision, General Laws § 27-10.4-1. Its stated goal is to require insurers to pay an insured’s chosen appraiser and, when used, the umpire appraiser directly if the insured or claimant gives the insurer a direction to pay.

  • An insurer would be prohibited from refusing that direction to pay.
  • The direction must be made by the insured or claimant and cover the insured’s chosen appraiser and, if applicable, the umpire appraiser.
  • The bill’s text also includes appraisal rules on selecting appraisers, resolving disagreements, and allocating some costs. The current law is not supplied, so it is unclear which of those rules would be new and which would remain unchanged.
  • The bill has passed the Rhode Island Senate, but the supplied status does not show that it has become law. It would take effect upon passage.

What it means for you#

  • Insured people and claimants: If you use the appraisal process and give the insurer a direction to pay, the insurer could not refuse to pay your chosen appraiser directly. The bill does not require you to use appraisal or say that every disputed claim must go through it.
  • Appraisers and umpires: The proposed rule covers the insured’s chosen appraiser and an umpire, if one is used. It does not cover the insurer’s chosen appraiser.
  • Insurers: You would have to honor a direction to pay. The bill does not set a payment deadline or explain how to handle disputed bills.
  • Other insurance claims: The bill concerns motor vehicle appraisals under this provision; it does not directly change other insurance claims.

Money#

No government cost estimate or other fiscal information is in the supplied material.

  • The bill would require insurers to pay appraisers directly when they receive a direction to pay, but it gives no cost estimate, fee limit, or payment deadline.
  • The reproduced section says each side pays for its own appraiser. It also says an insurer must reimburse the insured’s or claimant’s appraisal costs if the final award is more than 25% above the insurer’s original offer. If the difference is less than 25%, the parties split the umpire’s cost. The supplied materials do not show whether these rules are new or already in current law.

What is unclear#

  • The current version of § 27-10.4-1 was not supplied, so the full difference between current law and the bill cannot be verified.
  • The bill does not explain whether the insurer may later seek payment from the insured or claimant when the existing cost rules assign costs to them.
  • It sets no required form, invoice rules, or deadline for paying after a direction is received.
  • The reproduced cost rules address awards more than or less than 25% above the original offer, but do not say what happens at exactly 25%.
  • The supplied status does not establish whether the bill has passed the full General Assembly or when it might take effect.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make direct payment available when an insured or claimant wants the insurer to pay the appraiser rather than route payment through them.
  • A possible argument for the rule is that it makes an insurer honor the insured’s payment instruction instead of leaving that choice to the insurer.
  • The bill ties the payment duty to a direction from the insured or claimant, rather than requiring direct payment in every appraisal.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain how direct payment fits with rules that assign some appraisal costs to the insured or claimant. That could leave uncertainty about who ultimately bears the cost.
  • It sets no payment deadline or process for resolving a disagreement about an appraiser’s bill.
  • The full amended section includes other appraisal rules, but the available materials do not show how much of that wording would change current law.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1709165

    Passed37 members voted

    Passage

    FOR · 33AGAINST · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    33For

    • Democratic33

    4Against

    • Republican4

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1715469

    Passed10 members voted

    Senate Committee on Judiciary: Passage

    FOR · 10

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    10For

    • Democratic9
    • Republican1

    0Against