Local elections shift to odd years

Summary#

HB 1285 would amend South Dakota laws governing municipal and school district elections. Its stated goal, in the bill title, is to change when those elections are held. The supplied record identifies it as introduced; it does not establish that the bill became law.

  • Municipalities and school districts would hold regular elections in odd-numbered years, on the first Tuesday after the first Monday in June or November.
  • The bill would require municipal and school district elections to be held together in odd-numbered years, subject to approval by the other jurisdiction. The jurisdictions would agree on how to share election expenses and responsibilities.
  • It would change terms for several municipal and school board offices, including setting four-year terms for some offices. It also directs local governments and school boards to arrange vacancies so future elections have, as far as practicable, similar numbers of seats to fill.
  • People whose terms are set to expire in 2026, 2028, or 2030 would stay in office until they or another candidate are elected and qualified.
  • It would change rules for special elections and some voter petitions, including when a question must be put to voters at a regular election rather than a special one.

What it means for you#

  • Municipal and school district voters: Regular elections would be held in odd-numbered years, in June or November. Combined municipal and school district elections would use the same time, polling places, precinct officials, and ballots.
  • People seeking local office: Terms and election schedules would change for several municipal and school board positions. Some current office holders could remain in office past 2026, 2028, or 2030 until an election produces a qualified successor.
  • Municipalities and school districts: They would have to coordinate combined elections and agree how to share their expenses and governmental responsibilities. Municipalities would set their election date by January 14 of the election year; school boards would choose by resolution no later than their first regular meeting after January 1.
  • People affected by local petitions: Some questions that might otherwise go to a special election would instead be placed on a regular municipal election ballot if the bill’s timing conditions are met.
  • The bill does not change taxes, create a voter benefit, or require voters to vote in a particular way.

Money#

No publicly available information on an overall cost estimate.

  • For a combined municipal and school district election, the two jurisdictions must agree how to share expenses and governmental responsibilities.
  • The bill gives no estimate of election administration costs or any savings. It also does not say how much the new schedules or transition of terms would cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not provide an effective date.
  • It requires combined elections but also says they must be approved by the other jurisdiction. It is unclear what happens if approval is not given or the jurisdictions do not agree on the date or cost-sharing.
  • The bill changes terms and provides for transition years, but does not fully explain how each local government would set the initial schedules under the new system.
  • The supplied material does not show how the bill’s changes would interact with every existing election rule. In particular, it repeals provisions for combining municipal and school elections with even-year county elections, while another amended school-election provision still refers to a June primary election.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that holding municipal and school district elections together could let voters use one polling place and ballot for both jurisdictions.
  • The bill lets local governments choose between June and November for regular elections, rather than requiring a single date.
  • Setting recurring four-year terms and arranging vacancies across election years could make local election schedules more regular.
  • Routing some petitions to a regular election could avoid a separate special election when the timing requirements are met.

Case against#

  • Combined elections require coordination and an agreement on costs and responsibilities, but the bill does not provide a process for resolving disagreement.
  • The term changes and extensions could leave some office holders in place longer before voters choose a successor. That may reduce how often voters can decide who holds some local offices.
  • The bill requires elections to be combined while making approval by the other jurisdiction a condition. The text does not clearly resolve what happens if that condition is not met.
  • No cost estimate is provided, so the effect of changed election schedules and shared administration on local budgets is unknown.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1638417

    Passed12 members voted

    Deferred to the 41st legislative day

    FOR · 11AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    11For

    • Republican9
    • Democratic2

    1Against

    • Republican1

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.