Election equipment rules tighten testing and audits

Summary#

HB 1314 would amend South Dakota laws on election equipment, testing, audits and recounts. Its stated goal is not provided in the supplied material. The bill is listed at the introduced stage, so it is not law; the current versions of the amended statutes were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which existing rules would change and which would remain.

  • Election equipment could not connect to the internet, and ballot-marking devices could not save or count votes. Systems would need federal Election Assistance Commission standards certification and State Board of Elections approval before use.
  • Before approval, a vendor would have to give the system’s software source code to the Secretary of State. An independent person, selected by the board in consultation with the vendor and state party chairs, would examine it and report whether it works as represented and has no defects or errors. The code would not be open to public inspection.
  • Existing equipment approvals would expire under specified conditions: systems approved before January 1, 2026, would need reapproval before use after July 1, 2026; approval of a new system or a software or operating-system update would end the previous approval on the following December 31.
  • Vendors would have to maintain election systems and keep operating systems, software patches and antivirus software current. If equipment could not be used because it was not updated, the jurisdiction would have to hand-count ballots, and the vendor would have to pay the resulting costs.
  • Counties would audit every precinct and every contest in elections counted with automatic tabulating equipment. Recounts would require manual counting of all votes in the election being recounted.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: The bill does not directly change who can vote or what appears on a ballot. It changes equipment approval and how votes may be tested, audited and recounted.
  • County election officials: They would have to conduct the main equipment test on the first Saturday before the 60th day before an election, at 9 a.m. local time. The test and any further testing would be open to the public. The bill also changes notice requirements and makes audit and recount work more extensive.
  • Counties: Auditors would have to audit all precincts and contests after elections counted by equipment. The audit would begin at 9 a.m. on the first Friday after the election. The bill provides for state reimbursement of audit costs, but the board would set reimbursable expenses and rates by rule.
  • Vendors: They would have to provide source code for examination, maintain systems and install current software and security updates. They would pay costs if their system’s failure to meet the update requirement forces a jurisdiction to hand-count ballots.
  • Candidates, parties and ballot-question committees: They would receive notice of equipment tests. The audit results would be sent to the Secretary of State and published on the Secretary of State’s website.
  • People requesting recounts: A recount would be a manual count. The bill would also repeal a special rule giving candidates extra time to request a recount after an audit found a discrepancy larger than the election margin.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s total costs or savings.

  • The state would reimburse counties for qualifying post-election audit costs, at rates and under rules set by the State Board of Elections.
  • Vendors would have to pay costs caused by a required hand count when their system could not be used because it lacked current operating-system software, patches or antivirus software.
  • The bill provides no estimates for audit, staffing, equipment approval, software maintenance or hand-count costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not explain the full process or deadlines for system and software approval, including how quickly an updated system could be approved.
  • It does not set standards for choosing the independent source-code examiner beyond consultation with the vendor and party chairs, or explain how the examiner would check whether code is free from errors.
  • The bill says source code is not open to public inspection. It does not explain what information, if any, the public would receive beyond the examiner’s statement.
  • “Most current” software, patches and antivirus software are not defined in the bill text.
  • The bill sets transition dates but does not explain what happens if a county’s system cannot receive approval in time.
  • The current statutes were not supplied, so the full effect of changing existing testing and audit rules cannot be verified.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that examining source code and requiring current software could give the state more ways to check that election systems work as vendors claim.
  • Public tests, public selection of audit precincts and contests, and publication of audit results could make more of the checking process visible.
  • Auditing every precinct and contest would check a broader set of results than an audit limited to some precincts and contests.
  • Requiring manual recounts could provide a count that does not rely on the equipment used to produce the original results.

Case against#

  • Requiring audits of every precinct and contest, and manual recounts, could demand substantial staff time and money. The bill does not estimate those costs.
  • If equipment cannot meet the update requirement, a county must hand-count ballots; the bill does not explain how quickly vendors or counties could resolve approval or update problems.
  • The bill makes source code confidential, so the public could not inspect it, and it does not specify the examiner’s review standards.
  • The transition dates could require counties to replace or reapprove systems on a short timetable; the bill does not explain what happens if approval is delayed.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1630975

    Passed12 members voted

    Deferred to the 41st legislative day

    FOR · 9AGAINST · 3

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    9For

    • Republican7
    • Democratic2

    3Against

    • Republican3

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.