Election board abolition shifts duties

Summary#

HB 1324 is a bill to abolish the South Dakota State Board of Elections. It amends election laws and shifts many duties and powers from the board to the secretary of state; its stated goal is abolition of the board. The supplied text is incomplete and does not include the bill’s ending, so it may not show every change.

  • The secretary of state would take over election rulemaking and other duties now assigned in the bill text to the board, including setting forms and procedures for petitions, elections, voter records, and post-election audits.
  • The bill would bar ranked-choice voting systems for state and local offices.
  • Some counties would have to provide a Sioux-language interpreter in each precinct if they meet specified language and literacy tests and are notified by the secretary of state.
  • It would change rules on voter registration, voter-record privacy and removal, voter challenges, and candidate and ballot petitions.
  • It would restrict the sources from which the state and political subdivisions may accept money or gifts for election costs.

What it means for you#

  • Voters and election officials: The secretary of state would have the listed election duties and rulemaking powers instead of the State Board of Elections. Counties and other election officials would have to follow the resulting rules. The bill does not create a new independent election agency.
  • Voters: Ranked-choice voting would not be allowed under the bill. The bill also changes registration and voter-record rules, but the supplied text does not let us reliably identify every change from current law.
  • Voters who need language help: A county would have to provide an interpreter proficient in a local Sioux dialect and English in each precinct if the county meets the bill’s thresholds and the secretary of state notifies it. A county auditor and state’s attorney could certify that a precinct does not need an interpreter, with supporting documents. A county state’s attorney could also seek a federal court order exempting the whole county.
  • Counties and other local governments: The bill assigns interpreter costs to the county general fund or the appropriate fund of the government running the election. It also gives local governments no option to adopt or enforce ranked-choice voting.
  • Petition sponsors and candidates: The bill changes petition forms, filing rules, and some nomination requirements. The supplied text appears to give conflicting deadlines for some initiative signatures, and its formatting does not reliably show which wording is being added or deleted.

The bill is listed as introduced, not as law. The supplied status information says it was deferred by committee; it does not establish that the bill was enacted.

Money#

The bill requires some counties to pay interpreters, but no cost estimate is in the available material.

  • Interpreters must be paid the same amount as precinct deputies. Their costs would come from a county general fund or the appropriate fund of the political subdivision running the election.
  • The bill also requires the secretary of state to take on duties, but the available material gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The bill restricts which sources may provide election-cost funds. No estimate of any resulting change in public spending or revenue is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text ends partway through an amendment and does not include the full bill.
  • The text’s editing marks are not reliably visible. In some places, old and proposed wording appear together, making it hard to tell exactly what would change.
  • The petition-signature deadlines appear inconsistent: one provision says the first Tuesday in February, while another says the first Tuesday in May.
  • The current versions of the laws being amended were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which rules are new and which restate existing law.
  • The bill leaves important implementation details to future rules, including interpreter qualifications and how the secretary of state would notify counties.
  • No start date or fiscal estimate is shown in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to simplify election administration by placing many duties with the secretary of state rather than a separate board.
  • A single state office setting forms and procedures could make responsibility for election rules more direct.
  • Requiring interpreters in qualifying precincts could give some voters language assistance with voting instructions.
  • Limiting election funding sources could reduce the role of non-government funding in election costs.

Case against#

  • Moving duties and rulemaking to the secretary of state concentrates election authority in one office. The supplied text does not explain what independent oversight would replace the board’s role.
  • Interpreter requirements could add costs for counties, but the bill provides no estimate of how many counties or precincts would be affected.
  • The ban on ranked-choice voting removes that option for local governments as well as the state.
  • The bill changes many election rules at once, while the incomplete text and unclear editing marks make the full effects difficult to assess.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1639587

    Passed12 members voted

    Deferred to the 41st legislative day

    FOR · 12

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    12For

    • Republican10
    • Democratic2

    0Against

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.