Minors' data would face tighter rules

Summary#

HB 1309 would create a new chapter in South Dakota law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to restrict how online services handle personal data of people age 16 or younger. The supplied status says the bill is at the introduced stage and was tabled; it is not law based on the supplied material.

  • An operator generally could not process a covered user’s personal data or let a third party process it, unless a listed exception applies.
  • A covered user is someone the operator actually knows is 16 or younger, or any user of a service targeted to people 16 or younger.
  • For users 12 or younger, processing is allowed if permitted under federal children’s privacy law and its regulations. For users 13 through 15, it requires a parent’s or legal guardian’s consent. There is no consent-based permission listed for users who are exactly 16.
  • Processing is also allowed when strictly necessary for one of eight listed purposes, including providing a requested service, certain internal business operations, security, legal compliance, and responding to government inquiries.
  • Within 14 days of determining a user is covered, an operator must delete or destroy that user’s personal data unless processing is allowed, and notify third parties that received or were allowed to process it.
  • The attorney general alone could enforce the chapter, seeking a court order to stop a violation or a civil penalty of up to $5,000 per violation. The operator must first get written notice and 60 days to cure.

What it means for you#

  • People age 16 or younger: If the bill became law, your personal data could be processed only under the bill’s exceptions. The bill does not create a private right to sue.
  • Parents or legal guardians: Consent would be required for processing data of users ages 13 through 15, unless a strict-necessity exception applies. The bill does not specify how consent must be obtained or checked.
  • Online operators: The definition includes services that collect data themselves, allow others to collect it, or allow users to publicly disclose it. Operators would have to meet the limits, deletion and notification duties, and any enforcement action.
  • Third parties: Operators would have to notify third parties that received or were allowed to process the data when the operator determines the user is covered. The bill does not directly impose a separate duty on those third parties.
  • The attorney general: The office would have exclusive enforcement power and could seek an order to stop a violation or impose a penalty after the notice-and-cure period.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill authorizes civil penalties of up to $5,000 per violation; collected penalties would go to the state general fund.
  • No estimate is provided for state enforcement costs or for operators’ costs to identify covered users, delete data, notify third parties, or obtain parental consent.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define when a service is “targeted” to people 16 or younger, or what “strictly necessary” means.
  • It does not explain how operators must determine a user’s age, how they must obtain or verify consent, or how they must handle an incorrect age determination.
  • The bill covers people who are 16, but its age-based permission rules specify users 12 or younger and users 13 to under 16. For 16-year-olds, only the strict-necessity exceptions are listed.
  • It does not set rules for the form of third-party notices, how quickly recipients must act, or how deletion is verified.
  • It does not define what counts as “each violation” for the penalty, or provide an effective date.
  • The bill’s status is supplied as “introduced” and “tabled”; its eventual passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to limit the collection and use of young people’s personal data, including data handled by third parties.
  • Parental consent for users ages 13 through 15 would give parents a role in permitting processing outside the listed exceptions.
  • The strict-necessity exceptions allow specified activities such as maintaining a requested service, fixing technical errors, and responding to security threats.
  • Deletion and third-party notice duties could extend the bill’s protections beyond the operator that first collected the data.

Case against#

  • The bill’s age rules leave a gap for 16-year-olds: it provides no parental-consent route for them, even though it defines them as covered users.
  • Undefined terms such as “targeted” and “strictly necessary” could make it hard for operators and users to know what processing is allowed.
  • The bill does not spell out age-checking, consent, or deletion procedures, while requiring action within 14 days of determining a user is covered.
  • The bill gives the attorney general sole enforcement authority and provides no private right of action; the supplied material does not explain how enforcement resources would be funded.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1639729

    Passed11 members voted

    Tabled

    FOR · 11

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    11For

    • Republican11

    0Against

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.