Data centers bear electricity costs and water limits

Summary#

SB-235, the “Data Center Bill of Rights for Citizens,” would add tax exemptions to existing tax chapters and create new data-center rules in Title 49. Its stated goal is to protect residents from utility costs and shortages linked to data centers. The supplied material does not include the existing tax laws, so I could not verify how these provisions would change current rules.

  • A data center operator would have to pay all costs associated with providing electricity to the data center. Electricity providers could not shift data-center costs to residential customers in the ways the bill lists.
  • The bill would preserve county, municipal, and other local governments’ authority to limit, prohibit, or regulate data centers.
  • Before operating, an operator would have to notify local water providers of projected water use. Providers would have to assess compatibility with local supply and give the operator a written determination.
  • The Board of Water Management would have to issue a public statement if every applicable water provider finds the projected use compatible. The Board would also set water-use limits by order, after accounting for residential needs and essential public services.
  • Operators would have to report water use to the Board twice a year. The Board would make usage data public.
  • Purchases made by a data center would be exempt from taxes imposed under Chapters 10-45 and 10-46.

What it means for you#

  • Residential utility customers: Providers could not charge residential customers higher fees, rates, or surcharges to finance, offset, or subsidize data-center costs. They also could not allocate costs attributable to a data center to residential customers. This is not a general freeze on utility bills.
  • Data center operators: You would have to pay electricity-provision costs, give local water providers advance notice of projected water use, and report water use twice a year. You could not use more local water than the limits set by Board order.
  • Local water providers: You would have to decide whether a proposed data center’s projected water use is compatible with local supply and issue a written determination.
  • Local governments: The state could not preempt or otherwise limit your authority to regulate, limit, or prohibit data centers. The bill does not require local governments to take action.
  • Taxpayers and the public: Data-center purchases would receive the stated tax exemptions. The bill does not say how much revenue those exemptions would reduce.

Money#

No cost or revenue estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • Data center operators would have to pay all costs associated with providing electricity to their facilities.
  • The tax exemptions could reduce tax revenue, but the amount is not stated.
  • The Board and local water providers would have new duties; the bill gives no staffing or administrative cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • “Data center” is defined broadly as a centralized repository for handling electronic data and information. The bill does not explain which facilities would qualify in practice.
  • The bill does not set criteria or a deadline for water providers’ compatibility determinations. It also does not explain what happens if a provider finds projected use incompatible.
  • The Board would set water limits by order, but the bill does not specify the process, standards, or appeal rights for those limits.
  • The bill does not define how “all costs” of providing electricity would be calculated or settle disputes over which costs are attributable to a data center.
  • The text does not specify the start date, enforcement process, or penalties for failing to meet its requirements.
  • The supplied material does not include the current tax chapters or other current law, so the existing tax treatment and any overlap with current rules could not be checked.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that data centers should bear the electricity costs they cause rather than shifting those costs to residential customers.
  • Requiring advance water-use notice and public reporting could give local providers and the public information about projected and actual use.
  • Setting water limits after residential and essential public-service needs are accounted for could help protect those uses.
  • Preserving local authority would let communities decide whether and how data centers should operate in their area.

Case against#

  • The bill does not spell out how electricity costs are attributed to a data center, which could lead to disputes among operators, providers, and regulators.
  • Water compatibility findings and Board limits could depend on standards and processes the bill does not provide.
  • The purchase tax exemptions could reduce public revenue, while the bill provides no estimate or explanation of how that revenue would be replaced.
  • The bill adds duties for the Board and local water providers but does not provide funding or explain how those duties would be carried out.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1638120

    Defeated9 members voted

    Do Pass Amended

    AGAINST · 5FOR · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    5Against

    • Republican5

    4For

    • Republican3
    • Democratic1
  2. Division No. 1638121

    Passed9 members voted

    Deferred to the 41st legislative day

    FOR · 5AGAINST · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    5For

    • Republican5

    4Against

    • Republican3
    • Democratic1