Tribes to receive tax-collection estimates

Summary#

SB 241 would add three new sections to South Dakota’s tax collection law, Chapter 10-12A. Its stated goal is to require annual reports to Indian tribes about estimates of certain tax collections; the bill would not itself give tribes tax revenue. The supplied status says the bill was introduced and deferred by the Senate Taxation Committee; it is not law.

  • The Department of Revenue must report to each tribe that has a tax collection agreement, estimating collections under that agreement in the area it covers. Reports must separate collections from remote and nonremote sellers.
  • The Department must also report estimates for each tribe based on the share of a county’s population made up of that tribe’s members, using the latest federal census. This applies to collections under tax agreements in 20 named counties and must also separate remote and nonremote sellers.
  • For both kinds of reports, the Department must provide reports covering 2020–2025 by December 1, 2026, then report each year on the prior calendar year.
  • If the Department lacks information needed for either report, it must develop and maintain a method to collect and report it.

What it means for you#

  • Indian tribes: Tribes covered by a tax collection agreement would receive estimates for collections within the agreement area. The second report is addressed to each tribe and estimates collections in the 20 named counties using that tribe’s share of the county population.
  • Department of Revenue: It would have to prepare the reports and, when needed information is missing, develop and maintain a collection and reporting method.
  • Tribal members and sellers: The bill does not change tax rates, create a tax payment, or require sellers or tribal members to submit information. It requires reports about estimated collections, not payments to tribes.
  • Current law: The text of Chapter 10-12A and Chapter 1-24 was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how these reporting duties would interact with current law or existing agreements.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Department would have to prepare reports and, if needed, develop and maintain a method to collect and report information. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The bill does not set a payment to tribes, change tax rates, or state that reported amounts would be transferred or returned to them.

What is unclear#

  • The bill refers to the taxes listed in Chapter 10-12A’s tax provision, but that provision was not supplied, so the taxes covered cannot be identified here.
  • The bill does not explain how the Department must develop its method, what information sources it may use, or how it should handle missing or conflicting data.
  • The second report uses a tribe’s share of a county’s population to estimate taxes collected from that tribe’s members. The bill does not explain how that estimate would account for where people live or where purchases occur.
  • The bill does not set out a way for a tribe to question or correct an estimate, or say how reports must be delivered.
  • The text does not define “remote sellers” or explain how the Department should classify them.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that tribes would receive regular information about tax collections connected to agreements and areas that affect them.
  • The reports would distinguish remote from nonremote sellers, which could make the estimates more detailed.
  • The bill requires reports for 2020–2025 as well as annual reports going forward, giving tribes estimates for earlier years.
  • Requiring the Department to develop a method when information is missing could help make the reporting duty workable.

Case against#

  • The second report relies on population shares to estimate taxes collected from tribal members. That may not match actual collections from those members.
  • The bill requires estimates but does not require the Department to pay tribes, change an agreement, or take action based on a report.
  • The method for collecting and estimating missing information is not specified, and the bill sets no review or correction process.
  • The added reporting and method-development duties could require staff or other resources, but the bill provides no cost estimate.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1637799

    Passed7 members voted

    Deferred to the 41st legislative day

    FOR · 4AGAINST · 3

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    4For

    • Republican4

    3Against

    • Republican3