Data Centers Face New Water and Tax Limits

Summary#

SB 338 would amend several Texas laws and add new requirements for data centers. Its stated goal, reflected in the title, is to address data centers; the bill does not state a more specific goal. It is an introduced bill, not law, and would take effect September 1, 2027, if enacted.

  • For new tax-abatement agreements, it would limit how much of a data center’s value can be exempted from municipal property taxes, and add required terms on cooling, water reporting, property ownership or leasing, environmental cleanup, and other conditions.
  • For certain agreements involving school-district maintenance and operations taxes, it would set a data center’s taxable value at no more than 50% of market value. It would also require notice and a 180-day period to cure or dispute a breach before termination, and recovery of lost tax revenue plus interest if the agreement is terminated.
  • Data centers meeting the bill’s size and other conditions and connecting to the ERCOT grid would have to register, use specified cooling systems, and report water use. Utilities would have to refuse or end grid connections in specified cases.
  • It would let the Public Utility Commission of Texas set rules on data-center noise, light, and building distance from a site boundary. It would also add stormwater-permit requirements and allow construction to be stopped in specified circumstances.
  • Municipalities could not make certain public loans or grants for data centers without an agreement meeting the bill’s requirements.

What it means for you#

  • Data center owners and lessees: For covered tax-abatement agreements made after the effective date, you would have to use one or more listed cooling systems, provide water estimates and later annual water-use reports, and pay for environmental harm to the covered property caused by construction, operation, presence, abandonment, or demolition. The bill requires an owner or lessee entering the municipal agreement to own or lease the data center for the agreement term.
  • Data center applicants for school-district tax agreements: The agreement would require the applicant to own the data center for the agreement term. If the governor or school district sought termination for a covered breach, the applicant would get written notice and 180 days to cure or dispute it, including through court action.
  • Data centers connecting to ERCOT: If the site meets the bill’s size and other criteria, the Public Utility Commission would have to set registration and water-reporting rules. Before connection, the customer would have to use an allowed cooling system and submit water estimates and sources. It would have to report water use and sources annually. A utility would have to disconnect a customer for using an unapproved system or failing to report on time.
  • Municipalities and other local taxing units: New agreements would have to follow the bill’s data-center conditions. A municipality’s tax abatement could not exempt more than 50% of the portion of property value otherwise eligible for abatement. A municipality terminating a covered agreement would have to recover lost property-tax revenue plus interest.
  • Residents and taxpayers: The bill does not directly change household tax rates, electricity rates, or water rights. Its rules could affect local tax breaks, data-center cooling and water reporting, and whether a covered site can connect to or remain on the ERCOT grid.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s public cost or fiscal effects is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill would require agency rulemaking, registration, and reporting, but provides no cost estimate or specific funding for that work.
  • Data-center owners or lessees would bear specified cooling, reporting, and environmental-remediation duties. The bill gives no estimate of those costs.
  • Tax-abatement limits could affect local tax revenue, but the bill provides no estimate of the effect. If certain agreements are terminated, the state or municipality must recover lost property-tax revenue plus interest.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the laws being amended were not supplied, so the existing rules—and how much of the bill’s tax and agreement language is new—could not be verified.
  • The Public Utility Commission must set some rules, but the bill does not provide all forms, deadlines, or compliance procedures. It also does not say whether water-use reports will be public.
  • The bill does not define “environmental harm” for the cleanup requirement. It also leaves some cooling-system determinations to the commission.
  • The bill does not specify how the commission would set noise, light, or distance standards, or how a municipality would handle a termination before imposing the required recovery.
  • The bill applies to agreements, grid connections, and permit applications on different timelines. It is unclear how its requirements would interact with other existing programs or rules.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it links public tax incentives for data centers to limits on cooling systems, water reporting, and cleanup costs.
  • Requiring water estimates before connection or an agreement, followed by annual reports, could give regulators information about data-center water use.
  • Requiring utilities to block or end a grid connection for specified failures makes some of the cooling and reporting rules enforceable.
  • The bill would limit the share of property value eligible for certain data-center tax breaks, while requiring recovery of lost tax revenue if covered agreements end for non-compliance.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill imposes detailed cooling and reporting requirements without stating their costs or providing a transition period beyond its effective-date rules.
  • The commission would have to write important rules, while the bill leaves some standards and compliance details open.
  • Requiring disconnection for a missed annual report or an unapproved cooling system could have significant consequences for a data center; the bill does not set out a separate review or appeal process for those utility actions.
  • The bill requires a permanent recorded limit on certain property interests under some agreements. That could constrain later owners or successors, although the bill provides exceptions when an interest has already been conveyed under specified agreements.