Programmable money limits denial grounds

Summary#

SB-298, the Programmable Money Amendments, is signed into law. It amends Utah’s Uniform Commercial Code and other existing Utah Code provisions, and adds sections on programmable money; its stated goal is to limit forced use and certain restrictions on transactions. The supplied bill text ends partway through the new rules, so their full wording is not available here.

  • The bill defines programmable money by features such as rules that control how or when it can be used, transaction approval or denial, expiration, or use in a social credit score system. An electronic payment system that only transfers non-programmable legal tender is excluded.
  • It excludes programmable money and central bank digital currency from the UCC definition of “money.” The visible text also excludes programmable money from the UCC definition of a deposit account.
  • A person may not require programmable money for a transaction unless they also accept or offer a free non-digital alternative.
  • The bill’s long title says an issuer may not deny or restrict transactions on specified grounds, including a person’s political opinions, religious beliefs, medical history, lawful firearm ownership, or compliance with environmental, social, governance, or diversity standards.
  • The long title also says an affected party may request a detailed written reason for a denied transaction or ended service, due within 30 days, and may seek punitive damages or revocation of an issuer’s business authorization. The bill does not prohibit buying or selling cryptocurrency or other assets.

What it means for you#

  • People and businesses making payments: If someone requires you to use programmable money for a transaction, they must also accept or offer a free non-digital alternative. The bill does not require anyone to offer programmable money.
  • Users of programmable money: The long title describes limits on an issuer’s reasons for denying or restricting transactions. It also provides for a written explanation after a request and remedies an affected party may seek. These are not guarantees that every disputed transaction will be reversed or that damages will be awarded.
  • Issuers: The bill adds restrictions and response duties described in the long title. The supplied text does not show the full rules or which issuers are covered.
  • General public: This is mainly a change to commercial law, not a new public payment program. It does not, according to the bill’s long title, ban cryptocurrency or other asset transactions.

Money#

The bill appropriates no money, but the available material gives no estimate of other public or private costs.

  • The free-alternative rule could require a person who requires programmable money to provide or accept a non-digital option at no charge.
  • The bill’s long title describes issuer duties and possible legal remedies, but the supplied material gives no estimates for compliance, disputes, or enforcement costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text stops partway through the new provisions. It does not include the full rules on prohibited transaction decisions, written explanations, remedies, or enforcement.
  • The definition of programmable money is visible, but the full definitions and scope of “issuer” and “aggrieved party” are not available here.
  • The materials do not show how a claim would be filed, what standards would apply, who could revoke an issuer’s business authorization, or what limits apply to punitive damages.
  • The bill provides a special effective date, but the supplied text does not state that date.
  • The current versions of the amended laws were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how much of the amended UCC wording changes existing law and how much is carried forward.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that people should not have to use money that can be restricted by programmed conditions without a free non-digital option.
  • Limits on certain denial criteria could protect people from transaction restrictions based on personal beliefs, medical history, or lawful firearm ownership.
  • Requiring a written reason after a request could give an affected party information to assess a denial or ended service.
  • The bill preserves the ability to buy and sell cryptocurrency and other assets.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the definition covers several different features, from transaction controls to expiration, without the supplied text explaining how borderline cases would be treated.
  • It is unclear how the free alternative must work in practice, or what happens if the alternative is not genuinely usable for a transaction.
  • The available material does not show the standards or process for seeking punitive damages or revoking an issuer’s business authorization. Those remedies could lead to disputes, while leaving affected parties unsure how to proceed.
  • Excluding programmable money from UCC definitions may affect how commercial-law rules apply to it; the supplied text does not explain the consequences in detail.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1648124

    Passed26 members voted

    Senate/ passed 3rd reading

    FOR · 25AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    25For

    • Republican20
    • Democratic4
    • Independent1

    1Against

    • Democratic1

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1647274

    Passed26 members voted

    Senate/ passed 2nd reading

    FOR · 20AGAINST · 6

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    20For

    • Republican19
    • Independent1

    6Against

    • Democratic6

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1639121

    Passed6 members voted

    Senate Comm - Substitute Recommendation

    FOR · 6

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    6For

    • Republican5
    • Democratic1

    0Against

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  4. Division No. 1639122

    Passed6 members voted

    Senate Comm - Favorable Recommendation

    FOR · 5AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    5For

    • Republican5

    1Against

    • Democratic1

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.