Pricing data rules would limit price discrimination

Summary#

SB-293, “Consumer Pricing Data Amendments,” would create Utah’s Consumer Pricing Act and amend the existing law that lists the Division of Consumer Protection’s duties. Its stated goal is to set rules for how suppliers use consumer data when pricing goods and services. The bill failed, so it did not become law.

  • Suppliers generally could not use a consumer’s personal data, biometric data, purchase history, or an inference from that data to raise the price charged to that individual.
  • The bill would allow those types of data to be used for loyalty programs, discounts, promotions, lower subscription prices, and certain prices based on location and broader market conditions.
  • A supplier using an automatic pricing system to raise a price would have to keep the price charged and the categories of personal data used for at least one year.
  • The existing Division of Consumer Protection, within the Department of Commerce, would administer and enforce the new Act. It could impose administrative fines of up to $2,500 and bring court actions.
  • Courts could order injunctions, disgorgement (giving up money received in violation), payment of disgorged money to injured consumers, fines of up to $2,500, and other reasonable relief.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: If the bill became law, a supplier generally could not use your personal data, biometric data, purchase history, or an inference from them to charge you more. The bill would not ban all price differences or all automatic pricing.
  • Consumers: Suppliers could still use that information for the listed exceptions. For example, they could use it to offer a discount or run a customer loyalty program. A supplier could use location information to set a price based on supply or demand, location-based operating costs, or other broad market conditions not linked to a specific person or device.
  • Suppliers: The rules would apply to people and businesses that regularly solicit, engage in, or enforce consumer transactions, whether or not they deal directly with consumers. Certain financial institutions subject to specified federal data privacy and security requirements are excluded.
  • Suppliers using automatic pricing: If such a system raised a price, the supplier would have to store that price and each category of personal data used in the increase for at least one year. It would not have to keep the characteristics used to create those categories.
  • Public: The bill would give enforcement duties to an existing division, not create a new independent agency. It does not set up a consumer application or review process. The bill also does not expressly create a consumer lawsuit, though it says other rights and remedies under state and federal law remain available.

Money#

The bill appropriates no money, but it does not provide an estimate of public or private costs.

  • Suppliers would have to store and retain certain pricing information when an automatic pricing system raises a price. No cost estimate is provided.
  • The Division of Consumer Protection would have to administer and enforce the Act. No publicly available information on added staffing or enforcement costs.
  • The bill would authorize administrative and court fines, but fines would depend on violations and enforcement.

What is unclear#

  • The bill uses definitions of “consumer,” “personal data,” and “biometric data” from other Utah laws; those laws were not supplied, so their full scope could not be checked.
  • The bill does not explain how a supplier must determine or document that a price increase was based on a permitted broad market condition rather than data linked to a specific person or device.
  • It does not set complaint procedures, investigation deadlines, or reporting requirements.
  • The supplied material does not include the current text of the amended law, so I could not verify the division’s existing powers or the full effect of changes to its duties list.
  • No publicly available information on how the new rules would interact with other pricing or consumer-protection laws.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent suppliers from using information about an individual to charge that person more.
  • Requiring records when automatic pricing raises a price could help the division investigate whether the law was followed.
  • The exceptions would preserve specified uses, including discounts, loyalty programs, and prices based on broader supply, demand, or operating costs.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define in this text how to measure a price “increase,” which could make it unclear when a supplier has broken the rule.
  • The exceptions allow several uses of consumer data in pricing, and the bill does not spell out how compliance would be checked.
  • The recordkeeping duty applies only when an automatic pricing system raises a price; the bill does not require the same records for other ways of setting prices.
  • The bill provides no funding estimate or added staffing details for enforcement, so the resources available to carry out the new duty are unclear.