City rezones for mass-timber rental housing

Summary#

Council approved in principle the rezoning at 7525 Cambie Street, from C-1 (Commercial) to a site-specific CD-1 (Comprehensive Development) district. It also approved related changes to the Sign and Noise Control bylaws, conditional on the CD-1 bylaw being approved. The stated goal is to support a mass-timber building and add rental housing.

  • The approved-in-principle plan is for a 12-storey, 48-metre building with 97 market rental homes and ground-floor commercial space. The maximum floor space ratio (FSR, building floor area compared with site area) would rise from 1.2 to 4.26.
  • The homes would be secured by a Housing Agreement for at least 60 years or the life of the building, whichever is longer.
  • The project does not include the standard 20% below-market rental requirement that would otherwise apply under the Transit-Oriented Areas policy, according to the staff report.
  • The approval is subject to conditions. It creates no legal rights for the applicant; the rezoning takes effect only if Council later enacts the CD-1 bylaw.

What it means for you#

  • Future renters: If built as approved, the building would provide 97 market rental homes. The report says 40% would have two or three bedrooms. It does not set out specific rents.
  • People seeking below-market rentals: The project is not required to provide the standard 20% below-market component. The report says this exception is intended to support the project’s viability as a mass-timber pilot.
  • Nearby residents: The approved-in-principle plan allows a taller and denser building than the current zoning. Residents who commented raised concerns about height, shadows, views, parking and local infrastructure.
  • The owner and project team: They must meet the approval conditions and obtain the later bylaw enactments before the rezoning takes effect. Costs they incur are at their own risk.
  • People using the site: It is currently used as a community garden. The decision does not say when or whether that use would end.
  • General public: The decision does not itself create a new housing service or guarantee that the building will be constructed.

Money#

City staff expect the project to pay development cost levies (DCLs), but the available material gives no estimate of public costs for the project.

  • Staff estimate DCLs of $1,347,074 and a possible waiver worth $1,334,498 for the residential floor area. The applicant requested a Class B waiver.
  • Staff say no community amenity contribution is anticipated.
  • The approval requires no stated City spending amount. The decision says project-related costs are at the person’s risk if incurred before the bylaws are enacted.

What is unclear#

  • When the CD-1 bylaw and related bylaw changes will come back for enactment, or whether all conditions will be met.
  • What rents the 97 market rental homes would charge; the supplied material gives no rent figures.
  • How parking would be arranged. The report describes one underground parking level accessed from the lane, but also refers to above-grade parking as a cost-mitigation pilot.
  • Whether and when the community garden would close or move.
  • The final amount of any DCL waiver and the project’s final contribution arrangements.

Case for#

  • City staff say the project would add 97 rental homes, with all homes secured for at least 60 years or the building’s life.
  • Staff say ground-floor shops and a site near transit fit the area’s mixed-use plans. Residents who commented also supported the retail and location.
  • Staff say mass timber can reduce construction-related carbon and on-site construction impacts; the project is also intended to test whether this building type is viable for wider use.

Case against#

  • Residents who commented raised concerns about the 12-storey height, including shadows, blocked views, privacy and effects on neighbourhood character. Sixteen of the 35 submissions expressed concerns about height, neighbourhood character or parking.
  • The project omits the usual 20% below-market rental component for this policy area. A possible trade-off is more market rental housing without that below-market set-aside.
  • Residents also raised concerns that parking and local infrastructure may not keep pace with the number of homes. Staff say the site must meet the Parking By-law and do not expect it to add pressure to street parking, but the supplied material does not set out upgrades to local infrastructure.