Summary#
Vancouver City Council unanimously approved in principle a site-specific rezoning for 1045 Haro Street and 830–850 Thurlow Street. It would change the site from DD (Downtown) to CD-1 (Comprehensive Development), allowing more floor space but a lower maximum height; the stated goal is to enable a mixed-use rental development. The rezoning is not yet in force: the City must still enact the CD-1 by-law, and Council’s approval in principle does not require the City to do so.
- The proposal is for 26- and 25-storey towers joined by an eight-storey podium, with 542 rental homes, a private childcare facility and ground-floor commercial space.
- The proposed maximum floor space ratio (FSR, the amount of floor area allowed compared with the site area) rises from 6.0 to 10.6. Maximum height falls from 137.2 m to 80.9 m.
- About 22 homes—3.8% of residential floor area—would be below-market rentals. All 542 homes would be secured through a Housing Agreement and covenant for at least 60 years or the life of the building, whichever is longer.
- If the CD-1 by-law is enacted, related Sign and Noise Control by-law changes would apply to the site. A Housing Agreement by-law must be enacted before the CD-1 by-law.
- Approval is subject to conditions, including a tenant relocation plan for eligible existing tenants before a development permit can be issued.
What it means for you#
- Existing tenants: The report says 87 existing tenancies are eligible for the City’s Tenant Relocation and Protection Policy. The applicant must submit a plan meeting that policy before a development permit is issued. The decision does not itself set out each tenant’s relocation arrangements.
- Future renters: The proposal includes 520 market-rental homes and about 22 below-market-rental homes. A non-profit must operate the below-market homes; the applicant intends YWCA to do so under a 60-year lease. At least one-third of those homes would have rents no higher than the shelter component of Income Assistance; at least one-third would be rented at no more than 30% of household income for eligible households; the rest would be at least 20% below the city-wide average market rent at initial tenancy and turnover.
- Nearby residents and businesses: City staff estimate the proposal would add about 47 minutes of shadow on Robson Village during the fall equinox. Conditions include pedestrian and street improvements and a construction mitigation plan at building-permit stage.
- Everyone else: The decision does not itself approve construction or make the rezoning effective. The City retains discretion over whether to enact the by-law.
Money#
The report estimates $14,708,000 in development cost levies and $908,079 for public art; it gives no estimate of City costs.
- The report says no community amenity contribution is anticipated, based on the cost of securing the rental homes.
- It does not state whether the levy and public-art estimates include taxes.
- No estimate is given for City staffing or other costs, construction costs, or the costs of tenant relocation.
What is unclear#
- When, or whether, the City will enact the CD-1 by-law; approval in principle does not guarantee enactment.
- The final development permit design, including the final parking and loading arrangements.
- The final terms of the Housing Agreement and who will operate the below-market homes; YWCA is described as the intended operator.
- The specific relocation arrangements for eligible tenants and the final rent amounts for the below-market homes.
Case for#
- City staff say the site’s plans support residential use and allow added height and density, and that the proposed form fits the area’s planning policies.
- The project would provide 542 rental homes, including about 22 below-market homes; 10 public comments supported new rental housing.
- Staff say the building’s stepped upper levels help limit shadowing while allowing the project to proceed. The Urban Design Panel supported the proposal, with recommendations reflected in approval conditions.
Case against#
- Residents who commented raised concerns about the buildings’ height and closeness to neighbours, including reduced daylight, blocked views and an overbearing effect.
- Staff estimate about 47 minutes of additional shadow on Robson Village during the fall equinox. Staff say removing that extra shadow would require reducing the towers by about five storeys.
- Eighteen public comments opposed the proposal, raising construction disruption, traffic congestion and affordability concerns. Some objected that about 22 below-market homes were too small a share and that existing tenancies could be lost.