Jail Limits for Technical Violations

Summary#

HB 1413 would amend and reenact two existing Virginia laws: the sections on dismissing certain criminal charges or probation-violation allegations, and on sentencing after a suspended sentence or probation is revoked. Its apparent goal is to limit jail time for technical probation violations and set rules for handling them.

The bill has passed the Virginia House of Delegates but is not yet law. The supplied text does not show how much of the proposed wording would change current law.

  • For an alleged violation of probation or a suspended sentence imposed after a felony conviction, a court would have to grant the Commonwealth’s motion to dismiss, with the defendant’s consent, unless it finds clear and convincing evidence that the motion resulted from bribery or bias against a victim based on a listed protected trait.
  • The bill lists 14 kinds of “technical violation,” including failing to report an arrest, follow probation-officer instructions, comply with treatment or monitoring, or appear in court. It also says violations after a prior sentencing or revocation hearing must be treated together as one technical violation.
  • A court could not impose active jail time for a first technical violation. For a second, it could impose up to 14 days only if it finds, by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not), that the person cannot safely be diverted from jail through less restrictive options.
  • For a third or later technical violation, the court could impose any sentence that could originally have been imposed. A first violation involving a firearm or loss of contact with the probation officer would count as a second; later violations of those kinds would count as third or later.
  • A person could defend against an alleged violation by showing substantial compliance with probation obligations. The bill also sets deadlines for hearings and limits how long a person may be held before adjudication.

What it means for you#

  • People on probation or with suspended sentences: Some failures to follow probation conditions would be treated as technical violations. For those violations, the bill would restrict when a court could impose jail time. It does not prevent jail for a new criminal conviction or for other violations that are not technical or good-conduct violations.
  • People held after an alleged technical violation: The court would have to give the case priority and docket it as soon as practicable. If it is not decided within 14 days, the person generally must be admitted to bail. Exceptions apply if the person agrees to further detention or the Commonwealth proves a significant risk of harm tied to substance use disorder or serious mental illness and the person has been referred for residential treatment. The bill sets an absolute 30-day limit on custody while awaiting a decision or sentence.
  • Courts and probation officers: The rules would affect how technical violations are grouped and sentenced. The bill does not create an application or review process for probationers.
  • People needing court-ordered treatment: A court could order the shortest jail term needed for an evaluation or participation in a drug, alcohol, or mental-health treatment program, even where the usual limits apply.
  • The public: The bill does not change the underlying criminal sentence for a new offense. It changes rules for certain dismissals and for violations of probation or suspended sentences.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Courts would have to prioritize certain cases and meet the bill’s timing rules, but the text gives no estimate of staffing or other costs.
  • The bill does not state a new fee, fine, tax, or appropriation.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the amended Code sections were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which rules are new and which are already law.
  • The text does not give a start date.
  • It does not explain how courts should decide whether someone can be “safely diverted” from jail, or what alternatives they must consider.
  • “Substantial compliance” and “significant risk of harm” are not defined in the supplied bill text.
  • The bill does not estimate how many cases, jail stays, or court resources would be affected. Its passage is also uncertain.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a technical failure to follow probation rules should not automatically lead to jail, especially the first time.
  • Treating multiple alleged violations since the last sentencing or revocation hearing as one violation could limit sentence increases based on several failures from the same period.
  • Priority hearings and a limit on pre-hearing custody could reduce the time people spend in jail while allegations are unresolved.
  • The substantial-compliance defense could let a person show that an alleged failure does not reflect a broader failure to follow probation.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the list of technical violations includes failures involving treatment, monitoring, court appearances, or contact with a probation officer. The bill does not spell out how courts should distinguish minor lapses from serious risks.
  • The court would have discretion to impose any originally available sentence for a third or later technical violation, but the bill does not set a further limit for those cases.
  • Counting a first firearm-related violation or loss of contact as a second violation means those allegations could lead to up to 14 days in jail if the court finds diversion unsafe.
  • The bill requires faster hearings and specific custody decisions but provides no cost estimate or details on the resources courts would need.