School Vendors Would Face Data Deletion Deadlines

Summary#

HB 1534 would amend the Code of Virginia by adding a section on school service providers and student and family personal information. Its stated goal, reflected in the bill’s title, is to require deletion of that information on set timelines. The bill is introduced and its committee referral is pending; it is not law.

  • A school service provider would have to delete all covered information within six months after its contract with a school or school division ends, unless state or federal law or regulation requires otherwise.
  • The provider would also have to delete relevant student personal information and family personal information within six months after a student graduates from high school.
  • The bill covers specified school-focused software, websites, apps, and online services. It excludes college and career readiness assessment services and services marketed for general use, even if also marketed to schools.
  • The duty applies to providers operating under contract with a school division or private elementary or secondary school. The bill does not create a new office, program, fee, or penalty.

What it means for you#

  • School service providers: You would have to meet the deletion deadlines. The bill does not set out a deletion request or review process.
  • Students and families: The bill would require deletion of covered information on those timelines, subject to legal retention requirements. It does not create a separate application process or state a right to sue or another remedy.
  • Schools and school-affiliated entities: The deletion duty is placed on providers, not directly on schools, school divisions, or entities such as booster clubs and parent-teacher associations.
  • People using general-purpose online services: The bill excludes services designed and marketed for general use, even if schools also use them.
  • Current law: The supplied material does not include the current Code or other relevant laws, so I cannot verify what deletion duties already apply or how this bill would interact with them.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s costs.

  • Providers would have to carry out the deletion duties, which may involve staff or other resources; the bill gives no cost estimate.
  • The bill does not specify public funding, fees, fines, or a new enforcement budget.

What is unclear#

  • “Relevant” student personal information is not defined. The bill also does not clearly explain whether the graduation deadline covers all family personal information linked to that student.
  • The bill does not explain how deletion duties apply when a provider has multiple school contracts or when another student’s information is held in the same records.
  • It does not set out monitoring, enforcement, penalties, reporting, or a process for resolving disputes.
  • The text gives no start date. It also does not explain how these duties relate to deletion requirements in other laws.
  • The bill defines a school service to include use by school-affiliated entities, but defines a provider by a contract with a school or school division. How those definitions apply when an affiliated entity uses a service without such a contract is unclear.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it sets deadlines for deleting covered information after a school contract ends or a student graduates.
  • Setting a deadline could limit how long providers keep information after those events, while allowing retention required by state or federal law.
  • The bill names family information as well as student information, recognizing that school services may collect data about students’ immediate family members.

Case against#

  • One concern is that “relevant” information and the graduation deadline’s treatment of family information are unclear, which may lead to differing interpretations.
  • The bill does not explain who will check compliance or what happens if a provider misses a deadline.
  • Providers may face staff or other costs to identify and delete information, but the bill provides no estimate or funding.
  • The exclusions leave out some services, including general-purpose tools used by schools, so the bill would not cover every online service that might hold school-related information.