Parental consent for minor online data use

Summary#

SB 232, “Consumer Data Protection Act; prohibitions and duties relating to minors,” would amend Virginia’s Consumer Data Protection Act and add rules for minors using online services, products, and features. Its stated goal is not given in the supplied material; the new rules would require parental consent for certain agreements and set duties for services dealing with known minors. The bill is introduced, not law; it would take effect January 1, 2027, if enacted.

  • A controller (the person or organization deciding how personal data is used) generally could not enter into a terms-of-service, user, or account agreement with a known minor without verified parental consent.
  • When seeking that consent, the controller would have to let the parent choose several protections, including the highest privacy setting, limits on data collection and use, no targeted ads or precise geolocation collection, and a block on purchases.
  • Controllers letting advertisers reach known minors would have to disclose specified information about each ad, including why it was targeted and how the minor’s data led to it.
  • Controllers using algorithms to suggest, promote, or rank information for known minors would have to explain the algorithms and how they use the minor’s data in their terms of service.
  • Controllers would have to use reasonable care to prevent a list of harms to known minors, including self-harm, bullying, sexual exploitation, illegal-to-minors ads, and predatory marketing.
  • Parents would gain a right to request a detailed copy of data a controller holds about a minor using its online service, product, or feature.

What it means for you#

  • Parents and minors: A parent’s verified consent would be needed for the covered agreements with a known minor. The bill lists ways to verify consent, including signed forms, calls, government ID, email steps, or another commercially reasonable method. It does not ban minors from using every online service: parental consent is an exception.
  • Parents: On consent, the controller would have to offer the listed privacy and data controls. A parent could also request data details, including sources, recipients, retention time, and any index or score assigned to the minor.
  • Online services and products: The new agreement, disclosure, algorithm, and reasonable-care duties would apply only within the Consumer Data Protection Act’s scope and subject to its exemptions. That Act generally covers businesses meeting data-processing thresholds; it exempts, among others, government bodies, nonprofits, and higher-education institutions.
  • Social media platforms: The supplied text does not make clear whether an existing one-hour daily limit for minors would remain. See “What is unclear.”
  • Other consumers: The bill does not directly change the Act’s general consumer data rights for adults, nor does it create a new agency or a direct payment benefit.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill creates compliance duties for covered controllers, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate, staffing estimate, or funding source.
  • The bill does not specify a tax, fee, fine, or public appropriation.

What is unclear#

  • The current Consumer Data Protection Act text was not supplied, so I could not verify which amended provisions are new and which restate current law.
  • The supplied text mixes old and revised wording in the social-media section. It does not show clearly whether the one-hour daily limit is kept, removed, or changed.
  • “Known minor” is used but not defined in the supplied text. The general definition of “minor” is under 18, while the social-media section uses under 16.
  • The bill does not spell out how controllers determine that someone is a known minor, or set detailed rules for handling disagreements about age or parental consent.
  • “Reasonable care” and “similar” harms are not defined. The bill does not specify how compliance would be checked or how these duties interact with existing programs.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that parents would have a clear role before a minor enters an online service agreement, along with choices over privacy, advertising, location data, and purchases.
  • Ad disclosures could help parents and minors see why an ad appeared and how data was used to target it.
  • Algorithm disclosures and the reasonable-care duty could make controllers account for foreseeable risks to minors, rather than treating their use like adult use.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the consent requirement could apply broadly across online services, products, and features, while the bill leaves “known minor” undefined and gives limited detail on how age and consent are handled.
  • The reasonable-care duty covers serious harms but does not define its limits or set a detailed compliance process. That could leave controllers uncertain about what is required.
  • The bill does not estimate the cost of age checks, parental-consent tools, disclosures, or changes to services. Those costs are unknown.
  • The unclear social-media wording makes it difficult to know whether the bill would preserve or change the one-hour limit.