Data brokers face new safeguards

Summary#

HB 638, “Data brokers; regulation, civil penalties,” would add a new chapter to Title 59.1 of the Virginia Code; it does not amend a named existing Act. Its stated goal, reflected in its title, is to regulate data brokers. The bill is not law, and passage is uncertain; if enacted, it would take effect July 1, 2027.

  • Businesses that meet the bill’s definition of a data broker would have to maintain a written information-security program and register with the Secretary of the Commonwealth each year, starting December 1, 2027.
  • A data broker is generally a business whose main source of revenue is selling personally identifiable information about consumers it has no direct relationship with. The bill excludes some directory, professional-information, and health or safety alert services.
  • Any person would be barred from acquiring personal information through fraud, or acquiring or using it to stalk or harass someone, commit fraud, or engage in unlawful discrimination.
  • The Attorney General could enforce the rules after giving 30 days’ written notice. If the recipient cures the violation and promises in writing not to repeat it, the Attorney General may not start an action over that violation.
  • The bill exempts information covered by two named federal privacy laws. It says Virginia privacy laws, including the Consumer Data Protection Act, continue to apply where this chapter does not conflict with them.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: The bill would require brokers to report whether they offer opt-outs and what those opt-outs cover. It does not require every broker to offer an opt-out or create a general consumer right to access or delete information.
  • Data brokers: They would have to set up and maintain safeguards suited to their business, resources, and data. The required program includes staff responsibility, risk checks, employee training, vendor safeguards, regular review, and breach documentation. Where technically feasible, it must also include specified technical safeguards, including de-identifying personal information before it travels across public networks or is sent wirelessly, and before it is stored on portable devices.
  • Data brokers: Annual registration would require a $1,000 fee and public disclosures about their contact details, opt-outs, breaches, data categories, and certain sales or sharing—including sharing with governments, law enforcement, or AI system developers. The Secretary of the Commonwealth must post the information online.
  • People and businesses generally: The bans on obtaining or using information for the listed harmful purposes apply to any person, not only data brokers. The bill does not otherwise ban buying or selling personal information.
  • Virginia agencies and taxpayers: The Secretary would have to publish registration information, and the Attorney General would have exclusive enforcement authority. The bill does not set out an appropriation for those tasks.
  • People seeking to sue: The bill says it does not create a private right of action for violations of this chapter.

Money#

The bill sets a $1,000 annual registration fee for data brokers, but provides no cost estimate for government or businesses.

  • Data brokers would pay the fee and bear the costs of registration and required security measures.
  • Civil penalties could be up to $7,500 per violation. Penalties, expenses, and attorney fees collected would go to a state trust fund.
  • The Attorney General may seek reasonable investigation and case-preparation expenses, including attorney fees.
  • No publicly available information is provided on the cost of state administration or enforcement, or on the compliance costs for data brokers.

What is unclear#

  • The text does not explain how the new rules would interact in practice with the Consumer Data Protection Act and other Virginia privacy laws. The parent laws were not supplied, so their current requirements and any overlap could not be verified.
  • The bill does not define how to measure a broker’s “principal source of revenue” or count “each violation” for penalties.
  • It does not set a process for consumers to challenge a broker’s disclosures or make brokers offer opt-outs.
  • It requires information about minors when a broker has actual knowledge that it holds their information, but does not define how that knowledge is determined.
  • The bill gives no estimate of staffing, implementation, or enforcement costs.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make data brokers disclose more about what they collect, sell, and share, including certain sensitive data and information about minors.
  • Requiring written security programs, staff training, vendor safeguards, and regular reviews could make brokers more accountable for protecting information they hold.
  • A public registry could give consumers and officials a way to see which brokers offer opt-outs and what types of information they collect.
  • The 30-day notice and cure period gives a broker a chance to fix a violation before the Attorney General starts an action.

Case against#

  • The $1,000 fee and security requirements could impose significant costs, especially on brokers with fewer resources; the bill does not estimate those costs.
  • Important coverage and penalty terms are not fully explained, which could leave uncertainty about which businesses qualify and how penalties are counted.
  • The registry would report whether opt-outs exist but would not require brokers to offer them, so consumers may learn that their information is collected without gaining a way to stop it.
  • The technical safeguards are detailed, but the bill does not explain how regulators would assess whether they are feasible or appropriate in particular cases.