Bill would expand sales tax to digital services

Summary#

HB 978 would amend Virginia’s Retail Sales and Use Tax chapter, not create a separate tax program. It would define digital personal property as tangible personal property and expressly list services as taxable; its stated goal is not given in the supplied material. The bill is marked introduced and continued from the last session, so it is not law and passage is uncertain.

  • The listed taxable services include admissions; recreation, fitness, and sports facilities; nonmedical personal services and counseling; laundry and dry cleaning; companion animal care; certain home repair, landscaping, and cleaning; vehicle and other property repairs; delivery and shipping; storage; separately billed travel, event, and aesthetic planning; and digital services.
  • Digital services are software application services, computer-related services, website hosting and design, data storage, and digital subscription services. Digital personal property includes electronically delivered products such as software, audio and video, and reading materials that the purchaser owns or can keep accessing without another subscription or usage fee.
  • The tax would apply to digital services even when a business buys them, unless another exemption applies. The bill names limits and exceptions for some services, including medical procedures, veterinary procedures, and certain home repairs that require a permit.
  • Sellers of taxable services and property would be subject to the existing sales and use tax system. The bill amends existing tax law; it does not establish a separate service-tax agency or program.

What it means for you#

  • Customers: Purchases in the listed categories could be subject to sales or use tax. The supplied text does not show whether each service is newly taxable under current law.
  • Homeowners and residents: Direct-paid home repair or maintenance is listed when it does not require a state or local permit. Direct-paid residential landscaping and cleaning are also listed.
  • Businesses buying digital services: These purchases are expressly included, unless an existing exemption applies.
  • Service businesses and sellers: They would have to account for tax on covered sales under the tax chapter. The supplied text does not show all the related collection and filing rules.
  • General public: The bill does not create a new benefit, ban, or front-line service. It also does not show a start date in the supplied material.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • No fiscal estimate or revenue projection is included in the supplied material.
  • The bill would subject covered sales to the existing sales and use tax. The shown versions of the tax provision contain different rates, so the rate that would apply if the bill took effect cannot be confirmed from this incomplete text.
  • The bill text includes limits on some listed services and refers to existing exemptions, but the supplied material does not show all related tax provisions or how much revenue they might affect.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text ends partway through the amendments. It does not include the full changes to the listed tax and administration sections.
  • The current versions of the amended laws and explanatory notes are not supplied. I could not verify which listed services or digital products are already taxable and which would be newly covered.
  • The tax rate that would apply, the start date, and how the bill’s different versions of the rate provision fit together are not clear from the material.
  • The bill uses terms such as “computer-related services” and “software application services” without definitions in the supplied text.
  • The supplied material does not include detailed collection, filing, or enforcement changes, or explain how the new categories would interact with existing exemptions.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would apply sales and use tax to a broad set of services and digital products, rather than limiting the listed categories to physical goods.
  • Including digital services bought by businesses could make the tax rule apply to those transactions as well as consumer purchases, subject to exemptions.
  • The stated categories and exceptions could give sellers and customers more direction about which types of transactions the bill intends to cover.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the listed categories are broad, while some key terms are not defined in the supplied text. That could make it hard for sellers and customers to know which transactions are taxable.
  • The bill could increase the tax on purchases in covered categories, but the supplied material gives no estimate of the amount or who would ultimately bear the cost.
  • Because the text is incomplete and current law was not supplied, it is unclear how much the bill would change existing rules or how it would fit with current exemptions.