International Gift Certificate Sales Face 24-Hour Hold

Summary#

HB 689, “Gift certificates; amends definition, international transactions, fraud reports,” would amend the Code of Virginia and add a new section on fraud reports. It would require a 24-hour activation hold for certain gift-certificate sales and require local law enforcement to report gift-certificate fraud to a federal center. The bill does not state a separate goal.

  • A merchant selling a gift certificate in Virginia as part of an “international transaction” would have to wait 24 hours before activating it.
  • Local law enforcement that receives a report of gift-certificate fraud would have to communicate it immediately to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center.
  • The bill also rewrites the definition of “gift certificate” and reenacts rules on expiration and value-loss disclosures and fees. The supplied bill text does not show which definition wording is being removed or added, or how the reenacted rules differ from current law.

What it means for you#

  • Gift-certificate buyers: If a sale is part of an international transaction, the certificate could not be activated for 24 hours. The bill does not explain which transactions count.
  • Merchants: They would have to put the hold in place for those sales. The bill does not set out how to apply the hold or identify exceptions.
  • Local law enforcement: Officers receiving a gift-certificate fraud report would have to send it to the FBI center immediately.
  • Gift-certificate holders: The bill’s text includes disclosure rules for certificates with expiration dates or declining value, and a ban on certain fees except for certificates given through award, loyalty, or promotional programs with no other value exchanged. Because these rules are reenacted and the current Code text is not supplied, it is unclear what would change for holders.
  • General public: The bill does not create a new law-enforcement agency or a new consumer application or review process.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires merchants to hold activation for 24 hours and local law enforcement to report fraud, but gives no cost or staffing estimates.
  • No fee, fine, tax, appropriation, or funding source is specified.

What is unclear#

  • “International transaction” is not defined. The bill does not say how the 24-hour period is measured, how the hold must work, or whether exceptions apply.
  • The definition of “gift certificate” appears in conflicting versions in the supplied text. The bill’s amendment formatting is not available, so the exact proposed definition and its effect cannot be verified.
  • The current Code text was not supplied. It is therefore not possible to verify which disclosure and fee rules are already in force and what the reenacted wording would change.
  • The bill does not define what counts as a gift-certificate fraud report or set out how law enforcement must communicate it to the FBI center.
  • The bill is listed as introduced. It is not law, and the material gives no start date.

Case for#

  • A 24-hour hold could give time to identify or interrupt some fraudulent gift-certificate purchases. That is a possible effect, not a result guaranteed by the bill.
  • Requiring local law enforcement to share fraud reports with the FBI center could help get those reports to a federal body. The bill does not specify how the information would be used.

Case against#

  • The undefined term “international transaction” could leave merchants unsure when they must delay activation and could delay legitimate purchases.
  • The bill requires the hold but does not explain how merchants should apply it or handle disputed cases.
  • Immediate reporting could add work for local law enforcement, but the bill provides no estimate of that workload or cost.
  • The unclear definition makes it difficult to know which products would be covered by the bill’s rules.