Data centers face moratorium, new classifications

Summary#

SB 850, titled “Data centers, large; moratorium, approval requirements, utility independent classifications, report,” would amend the Code of Virginia and add new provisions on data centers, wages, utilities and environmental reporting. Its stated goal is to address the effects of data center development; that goal is not a guaranteed result. The bill is introduced and has been referred to committee, so it is not law.

  • The Department could not approve a large data center before July 1, 2028, with exceptions for certain existing approvals and projects already starting construction by July 1, 2027. Separately, localities could not give final approval to specified siting applications for any data center from July 1, 2027, until that restriction expires July 1, 2028.
  • Before approval, a large data center operator would have to hold at least one in-person hearing in a host community, give residents at least 30 days’ notice with specified project information, address efforts to reduce harm, and pay hearing expenses.
  • Before construction or a major expansion, a large data center would have to fund and carry out a community investment program. It would cover eligible home technologies, community infrastructure, measures addressing expected water and wastewater impacts, and recruitment and training of local workers.
  • The State Corporation Commission would have to require regulated water, gas and electric utilities to create separate service classifications for large data centers by July 1, 2031. The classifications must assign specified costs to those customers and protect other customers from certain cost increases. The Commission may also set financial surety rules.
  • Construction workers on data center projects with at least 5 megawatts of peak demand would have to be paid the prevailing wage. The bill also requires an environmental impact report by January 1, 2029, and requires the Department of Energy to set and annually update data center efficiency goals.

What it means for you#

  • Residents of host communities: Before a large data center approval, residents would get advance notice of a public hearing and information about projected energy and water use, local impacts and incentives. The bill requires a meaningful chance to comment, but does not require the operator to follow public preferences.
  • People in localities considering data centers: From July 1, 2027, to July 1, 2028, a locality could not give final approval to a rezoning, special exception, special use permit, site plan or plan of development for a data center. This local restriction covers data centers generally, not just those meeting the bill’s 20-megawatt threshold.
  • Large data center operators: They would face the hearing and community investment requirements, as well as separate utility service classifications. “Major expansion” means adding at least 20 megawatts of electric load.
  • Data center construction workers: Workers on projects involving a center with at least 5 megawatts of peak demand would be owed the prevailing wage. The bill treats an employer’s failure to pay as a wage-law violation.
  • Other utility customers: The bill directs utilities to assign specified data-center service costs to the data-center classification and to prevent increases in certain charges not directly tied to energy use. It does not guarantee that every utility bill will fall or stay unchanged.

Money#

The bill requires data center operators to pay hearing costs and fund community programs, but the available material gives no cost estimates.

  • Utilities would have to assign listed service and infrastructure costs, and the Commission’s implementation costs, to the large-data-center classification. The Commission would also set an adjustment mechanism for specified commodity-price increases attributable to those customers.
  • The bill requires prevailing wages on covered construction projects; it does not estimate the added wage cost.
  • Public agencies would have to conduct hearings, prepare reports and set goals. The bill supplies no staffing or budget estimate and makes no stated appropriation.
  • The bill does not quantify the value of the community programs or of existing or proposed public incentives.

What is unclear#

  • The bill relies on an existing tax-code definition of “data center,” but that definition was not supplied. The full current parent laws were also not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which parts of the amended utility-rate law are already in force and which wording would change.
  • The bill does not set the amount or value of community investments. It directs the Department to establish a program that considers community input and other factors, but leaves the calculation details to that process.
  • The bill does not explain how its water-impact exception, which refers to a utility-classification provision, would work in practice.
  • The Department of Energy must set efficiency goals, including requirements about waste-heat recycling and renewable electricity, but the bill does not state the percentages or operational details.
  • The bill does not state when its provisions would take effect generally. Passage is uncertain because it is still at the introduced stage.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a temporary pause and local hearings could give communities and agencies time to assess large projects before approvals are issued.
  • Requiring operators to fund local infrastructure, home technologies and water-impact measures could make some costs of development fall on the projects that create them.
  • Separate utility classifications could help prevent data-center service costs from being shifted to other utility customers.
  • A statewide report could give lawmakers and the public information on energy, water, land, pollution, incentives and effects on nearby communities.

Case against#

  • The approval pauses could delay projects, including projects that might otherwise proceed; the bill does not assess the effects of those delays.
  • The bill requires community programs but leaves their scale and calculation to a later process, making it hard to know what operators would owe or what communities would receive.
  • Some major rules—such as efficiency goals, financial surety requirements and utility-classification details—would be set later. The bill does not specify their final content.
  • The bill requires agencies and the Commission to do substantial work without stating the staff or funding needed.