Phone data preservation after crashes

Summary#

SB-376, “Motor vehicle collisions; preservation and collection of certain mobile telephone data,” would add a section to Virginia’s Code and amend the collision-reporting law. Its stated goal is to preserve certain phone and driving-monitoring data after a collision; preservation is not the same as giving a requester access to the data. The supplied status says the bill passed the Senate, but does not establish that it became law.

  • An attorney representing someone involved in a collision could ask another party’s mobile phone provider to preserve specified records for 180 days. The records must be available when the request arrives; the request may be renewed.
  • An insurer would have to say whether the person alleged to have caused or contributed to the collision used a driving-monitoring app or device. On request, the insurer would have to preserve related available data, or arrange for a connected third-party provider to preserve it, for 180 days.
  • For collisions meeting the reporting threshold—death, injury, or apparent property damage of at least $3,000—officers would have to ask about phone use and driving-monitoring apps or devices, and include specified information in their report.
  • Reports would include drivers’ phone numbers, providers, and IMEI numbers (device identifiers). IMEI numbers would be withheld from public copies, with exceptions for people involved in the collision and their attorneys.
  • The Department of Motor Vehicles would have to update its electronic data-entry screen for collision reports.

What it means for you#

  • People involved in a collision: If represented by an attorney, you could have your attorney request preservation of another party’s specified phone data before a personal-injury lawsuit is filed. The request must identify the collision and the parties. The attorney must notify the provider within 15 days if representation ends or the attorney decides not to file an action.
  • Drivers: Officers would ask about your phone use around the collision and whether you use a driving-monitoring app or device. You would be asked for your phone number, provider, and IMEI. If you refuse, the report must say so; the officer must explain how to find that information.
  • Phone providers: On a qualifying attorney’s written request, providers would have to preserve available records for four hours around the collision—two hours before and two hours after. The list includes subscriber details, call and text logs (not message content), IP addresses, device identifiers, cell-site or server access history, and real-time location data.
  • Insurers and connected app providers: Insurers would have to answer whether the alleged at-fault driver used a monitoring app or device. On request, they must preserve available data collected by that tool and received by its provider, or cause a connected third-party provider to preserve it.
  • People seeking the data: The bill creates a preservation process, not a right to receive the data. It does not itself require disclosure to an attorney or party; the text refers to records being subpoenaed or otherwise requested in a pending case.

Money#

The bill gives no overall cost estimate; it says the necessary appropriation for possible imprisonment costs cannot be determined.

  • The bill requires the DMV to update its electronic data-entry screen. No cost estimate is supplied.
  • The text says the bill may increase imprisonment or juvenile commitments. It says a minimum fiscal impact of $50,000 must be assigned for possible state adult imprisonment, but does not say that this is an actual appropriation or a full cost estimate.
  • No estimates are supplied for costs to law-enforcement agencies, insurers, phone providers, or app providers.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the current text of the collision-reporting law. It is therefore not possible to verify which reporting duties are new and which restate existing law.
  • The bill does not set rules for how providers must handle requests, verify them, or tell requesters whether data is available.
  • It does not explain how a party obtains preserved records, beyond referring to a subpoena or another request in a pending case.
  • “All data” from a driving-monitoring app or device is not defined. The bill also does not explain how that data-preservation duty would work if an insurer has no contract, agreement, or other relationship with the app provider.
  • The bill text does not explain why it may increase imprisonment or juvenile commitments.

Case for#

  • A collision can lead to a dispute about what happened. Preserving records soon after it may help keep relevant information from becoming unavailable before a case is filed.
  • The requests are limited to a specific collision, a named party, and a four-hour period around the collision.
  • The bill limits access to IMEI numbers in public reports while allowing people involved in the collision and their attorneys to receive them.

Case against#

  • Preserving sensitive location and communications records may affect privacy. The bill does not set out a process for reviewing or challenging a request.
  • The bill does not itself provide access to preserved data, so it may create duties and costs without making clear how or when a requester can obtain the records.
  • Phone providers, insurers, and app providers would have preservation duties, but the bill gives no cost estimate or detailed operating rules.
  • The bill requires IMEI numbers in reports, but makes them available to a broad group connected to a collision, including passengers and vehicle owners.