Pilot would pay private lawyers for indigent defense

Summary#

SB 848 would create a two-year pilot program in Newport News and Hampton for paying private attorneys appointed to represent indigent people in criminal cases. It would temporarily override Virginia law that conflicts with the pilot’s payment rules, including §19.2-163; the current text of that law was not supplied, so the existing rates and fee caps cannot be verified. The stated goal is to increase the availability of qualified appointed attorneys, not a guaranteed result.

  • Appointed attorneys would be paid $150 an hour for legal services reasonably performed. There would be no statutory or administrative fee cap if the request is documented and the court finds the amount reasonable and necessary.
  • Attorneys would have to submit detailed, itemized time records. The bill allows compensation for a single-charge defense carried through to its conclusion, and for a probation-violation charge at a hearing under §19.2-306.
  • If a defendant fails to appear and remains a fugitive for a year after a capias or show-cause summons, the case may count as concluded for compensation if the attorney appeared at a hearing for the defendant.
  • The General Assembly must appropriate enough money to run the pilot. The Office of the Executive Secretary of the Supreme Court of Virginia must develop needed forms, procedures, or guidance and report on the pilot by December 1, 2028.
  • The bill would expire on June 30, 2029. It is introduced and referred to committee, so it is not law; the text does not specify when the pilot would start.

What it means for you#

  • Indigent defendants in Newport News and Hampton: The pilot would apply to private attorneys appointed by a court to defend you in a criminal matter. The bill does not change who qualifies as indigent or create a new right to appointed counsel.
  • Appointed attorneys: You would be paid $150 per hour for reasonably performed legal services, with no fee cap if the court approves the documented request as reasonable and necessary. The bill requires detailed time entries.
  • State and local taxpayers: The Commonwealth would pay when the charge is under state law. A county, city, or town would pay when the charge is under its ordinance.
  • The courts and Supreme Court’s Executive Secretary: Courts would decide whether requested amounts are reasonable and necessary. The Executive Secretary’s Office must develop implementation materials; it may also require participating attorneys to provide more information.

Money#

The bill requires the General Assembly to appropriate sufficient funds, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • Total spending would depend on participating attorneys, cases, hours billed, and court-approved expenses.
  • The bill sets no cap on compensation requests that meet its documentation and court-approval conditions.
  • The bill does not set out a separate fee for defendants or identify an offsetting revenue source.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not give a start date for the two-year pilot, though it sets an expiry date of June 30, 2029.
  • It does not define “qualified” attorneys or explain how attorneys would participate or how cases would be assigned.
  • It does not set review timelines, appeal rules, or further standards for deciding whether fees and expenses are reasonable and necessary.
  • The current text of §19.2-163 and other potentially affected laws was not supplied, so how the pilot changes existing payment rules cannot be fully checked.
  • The report is due before the bill expires, but the bill does not say what happens to payments or cases still underway when the pilot ends.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address limited availability of private attorneys willing and qualified to take appointed criminal cases in these cities.
  • A $150 hourly rate and removal of fee caps for documented, court-approved requests could make compensation better reflect the work required.
  • Itemized time records and court review could help ensure payments are tied to services that were reasonably necessary.
  • The required report could give lawmakers information on participation, case types, hours, and payments before deciding whether to continue or change the pilot.

Case against#

  • With no fee cap, total public costs are uncertain; the bill requires sufficient appropriations but gives no estimate.
  • Court review is required, but the bill does not provide detailed standards or timelines for approving requests.
  • The bill does not explain how attorneys would be selected or how cases would be assigned, which could affect how broadly the pilot operates.
  • It is unclear how the pilot’s payment rules would interact with other existing rules beyond the bill’s stated override.