Auto damage appraisal could settle disputes

Summary#

SB 6359, “Creating a third-party claimant's right to appraisal under automobile liability insurance policies,” would add a section to Washington’s insurance law, Chapter 48.18 RCW. It would let a third-party claimant or an automobile liability insurer demand appraisal when they cannot agree on the amount of property damage. The bill’s stated goal is to offer a nonjudicial way to resolve that dispute; it is at first reading and is not law.

  • The right would apply to automobile liability policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2027.
  • Each side must choose an appraiser within 10 days of a written demand. If the appraisers cannot agree on an umpire within 15 days, either side may ask the insurance commissioner to appoint one.
  • An agreement by any two of the appraisers and umpire would bind the parties on the amount of loss.
  • Each side must pay for its own appraiser; they must split the umpire’s cost equally.
  • The commissioner must administer and enforce the section, and may make rules. An insurer that does not comply could face enforcement, including a fine of up to $10,000 per violation or suspension or revocation of its certificate of authority.

What it means for you#

  • People making a property damage claim against another driver’s insurer: If you and the insurer cannot agree on the amount of damage, either of you could demand appraisal. The bill lists repair costs, total-loss value, diminished value after repair, and loss of use, including reasonable rental costs or cash compensation, as property damage.
  • Claimants: You would have to pay for your own appraiser and half the umpire’s cost. The bill says you may still elect civil remedies in addition to or instead of appraisal.
  • Automobile liability insurers: They would have to follow the appraisal process for covered policies and pay for their own appraiser and half the umpire’s cost. The bill does not make an insurer liable for a claim where liability is otherwise disputed; appraisal is about the amount of loss.
  • The insurance commissioner: The commissioner must enforce the new section and may adopt rules. The bill does not change the legal measure of damages recoverable in tort.

Money#

No cost estimate or fiscal note is included in the supplied material. No publicly available information.

  • Claimants and insurers would each pay for their own appraiser, and split the umpire’s cost.
  • The commissioner could appoint an umpire and may adopt rules. The bill gives no estimate of staffing or other public costs.
  • Insurers could face fines of up to $10,000 per violation, but the bill gives no estimate of fine revenue.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how appraisal interacts with a dispute over who is legally responsible for the accident.
  • It does not set out a process for challenging or reviewing an appraisal decision, or explain how appraisal would interact with a later civil case.
  • The bill uses definitions of “competent” and “disinterested” from RCW 48.18.620. That section was not supplied, so its definitions and how the existing first-party appraisal rules work could not be verified against current law.
  • The bill does not set out other appraiser qualifications, how the appraisal is conducted, or how the amount of loss is presented to the appraisers.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives claimants another way to resolve disagreements over the amount of vehicle damage without relying only on a lawsuit.
  • Appraisal could offer a defined process: each side selects an appraiser, and an umpire can resolve differences if the appraisers do not agree.
  • The bill expressly includes repair costs, total-loss value, diminished value, and loss of use, while leaving the underlying tort measure of damages unchanged.

Case against#

  • One concern is that claimants must pay for their own appraiser and half the umpire’s cost, which could make appraisal costly for some claims.
  • The bill makes an agreement by any two of the three decision-makers binding on the amount of loss, but does not explain how that decision can be reviewed.
  • It is unclear how the process would work when the parties disagree about responsibility for the accident as well as the amount of damage.