New Economic Development Fund

Summary#

SB-1063, “Creating Economic Development Investment Fund,” would amend West Virginia’s Revenue Shortfall Reserve Fund law and create a new fund in the State Treasury. Its stated goal is to use long-term capital to support job-creating projects, industry recruitment, infrastructure for large industrial and energy users, and private investment. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • The Division of Economic Development would administer the new fund. Surplus revenue above the reserve-deposit limit would be transferred to it instead of lapsing to unappropriated surplus.
  • The fund may provide loans, revolving financing, equity participation, performance-based infrastructure grants, or other financial instruments the Secretary of Commerce considers appropriate.
  • Any recipient must sign a performance agreement with job creation or retention thresholds, private investment thresholds, and projected tax-base expansion.
  • The fund could not pay government operating expenses, salary increases, or recurring program spending. Each project could receive more than 25% of the fund balance only after prior notice to the Joint Committee on Government and Finance.
  • The fund must keep at least one year of projected project commitments in reserve, and the division must report on it annually.

What it means for you#

  • Businesses and project entities: A project could receive financing from the fund, but recipients must agree to the listed performance thresholds. The bill does not set application rules, selection criteria, or consequences for missing those thresholds.
  • State government: The Division of Economic Development must administer the fund and report on it. The Economic Development Authority or another state spending unit may help administer it.
  • Taxpayers and the general public: The bill redirects certain surplus revenue to an economic development fund. It does not directly change personal taxes, create an individual benefit, or require any project to receive funding.
  • State reserve funds: The bill changes the treatment of surplus revenue above the stated reserve-deposit limit. The Revenue Shortfall Reserve Fund remains in the amended law. The current text of that law was not supplied, so I could not verify every re-enacted provision against current law.

Money#

The bill authorizes the fund to spend money, but no cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • Surplus revenue above the limit for deposits to the Revenue Shortfall Reserve Fund would go to the new fund; the bill gives no amount or forecast.
  • The fund may retain its balance, interest, and other returns from year to year.
  • The bill requires the division to administer the fund, but gives no staffing or administrative-cost estimate.
  • No publicly available information is provided on expected project returns, losses, or the amount available for grants and other financing.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set project application, review, or selection rules, or say how decisions would be overseen.
  • It does not explain how the state would respond if a recipient misses its performance thresholds.
  • The bill does not define terms such as “large” industrial or energy users, or specify how projected tax-base expansion would be measured.
  • It does not give a start date for the fund or say how much money it is expected to receive.
  • The supplied text does not include the current version of the amended reserve law, so the full extent of changes to that law cannot be verified.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it creates a dedicated source of long-term financing for economic development projects rather than sending the specified surplus revenue to unappropriated surplus.
  • The range of permitted financing tools could let the state support projects in different ways, rather than relying only on grants.
  • Performance agreements and restrictions on operating costs could link funding to stated project commitments and limit some uses of the money.
  • Annual reporting and notice to the legislative committee for large project shares could provide information about fund activity.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the Secretary of Commerce broad discretion over which financial instruments are appropriate, but does not set project-selection standards or a review process.
  • It requires performance thresholds but does not say what happens if a recipient fails to meet them or how the state would enforce the agreement.
  • Moving surplus revenue to this fund means that money would not remain available as unappropriated surplus; the bill provides no estimate of the amount or the trade-off for other state needs.
  • The minimum-balance rule and the 25% notification rule do not, by themselves, establish how much funding is available for projects or ensure that project outcomes will meet the bill’s goals.