Dental prior authorization must use multiple factors

Summary#

SB 1136, titled “Prior authorization for treatment of severe misalignment or malocclusion of teeth under health insurance policies and plans,” would amend Wisconsin statutes and create two new statutory sections. Its stated goal is to stop covered plans from using only the Salzmann Evaluation Index when deciding prior authorization for treatment of severe tooth misalignment. The bill failed and is not law.

  • Disability insurance policies and self-insured health plans that cover dental and related services could not rely solely on that index for these prior authorization decisions.
  • The bill also makes the rule apply to specified state and local public employee plans, school district plans, cooperative health plans, limited service health organizations, preferred provider plans, and defined network plans.
  • It would not ban using the index as one factor. It would not require a plan to cover treatment or approve a request.
  • For plans affected by a collective bargaining agreement, the rule would apply at the later of the plan year beginning on the act’s effective date or when the agreement is newly established, extended, modified, or renewed.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking dental treatment: If your plan covers dental and related services and requires prior authorization for treatment of severe misalignment or malocclusion, the plan could not base its decision only on the Salzmann Evaluation Index. The bill would not guarantee coverage or approval, and would not remove prior authorization.
  • Insurers and plan administrators: They would have to avoid relying solely on that index for the covered decisions.
  • Public and other named plan sponsors: The bill extends the rule to specified public employee and other plan types. The supplied text does not describe a new application or review process.
  • Everyone: Because the bill failed, it does not change current coverage or plan decisions.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material. No publicly available information on the bill’s public or private costs.

  • Plans would have to comply if the bill became law, but any staffing or administrative costs are unknown.
  • The bill does not set a fee, fine, benefit payment, or appropriation.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “severe misalignment or malocclusion” or explain what other information a plan could use.
  • It does not set decision standards, timelines, appeal rights, reporting rules, or a specific enforcement process.
  • The parent statutes showing current requirements were not supplied, so the existing rules and how much of the bill’s wording would be new could not be verified.
  • The bill gives an effective-date formula, but because it failed, it has no effective date.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a prior authorization decision about treatment would not be allowed to rest on one index alone.
  • This could leave room for plans to consider other information in making those decisions.
  • The rule would apply across several listed kinds of insurance and self-insured plans, rather than only one plan type.

Case against#

  • The bill does not say what other standards plans should use, which could leave decisions less consistent across plans.
  • It does not explain how plans should assess severe misalignment or malocclusion, or how a person could challenge a decision.
  • Requiring plans to use more than the index alone could add administrative work, but the bill provides no cost estimate.