Mass communications reporting would require 24-hour filings

Summary#

AB 1235, “Reporting of mass communications,” would amend Wisconsin’s campaign-finance law in Chapter 11 and add new reporting rules. Its stated goal is to require more information about spending on certain mass communications; the bill failed and did not become law.

  • Political action committees, independent expenditure committees and recall committees would have to register within 10 business days after spending money or taking on an obligation to make a mass communication.
  • Registered committees covered by the bill would have to report the date, amount and recipient’s name and address for those spending obligations. The bill’s analysis says this excludes referendum committees and conduits.
  • A person that is not a committee and is not an individual would have to report within 24 hours after spending or taking on an obligation of $500 or more in total for a mass communication. The report would include contributor details as well as spending details.
  • “Mass distribution” means at least 500 substantially identical pieces; “mass electronic communication” means at least 500 substantially identical emails or faxes; and “mass telephoning” means at least 500 calls with a substantially identical message.
  • A bona fide poll is excluded from the definition only if it is made within 60 days before an election, refers to a clearly identified candidate on that election’s ballot, and has no reasonable interpretation other than an appeal to vote for or against that candidate.

What it means for you#

  • Political committees: The covered committees would face an added registration trigger and mass-communication spending reports. The bill does not set out a new review or approval process.
  • Organizations and other non-individual spenders: If they are not committees, they would have to file a report within 24 hours once their total spending or obligations for a mass communication reach $500. Reports would identify contributors, and give an individual contributor’s occupation if that person’s cumulative contributions exceed $200.
  • Individuals: The new $500 reporting rule for noncommittee spenders expressly excludes individuals. The bill would not directly change individual voters’ rights or require them to report their own communications.
  • People who give anonymously: A person required to report could not accept an anonymous contribution over $10. The bill also requires reports to describe anonymous contributions; for an amount over $10, the report must say whether it went to the common school fund or a charity and give the recipient’s name and mailing address.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would create reporting and registration duties, but gives no estimate of the cost to filers or the state.
  • It specifies no new fee, fine, appropriation or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the existing Chapter 11 text, so the exact differences from current law could not be checked. The bill analysis describes existing registration rules, but does not give a full comparison.
  • “Communications media” and “substantially identical” are not defined in the supplied bill text. The scope of communications covered may therefore be unclear.
  • The bill does not explain how a noncommittee person that receives an anonymous contribution over $10 must handle it. It bars that person from accepting it, but its donation instruction names committees.
  • The bill does not specify a new penalty or enforcement process for failing to register or report, or explain how the 24-hour deadline would apply to reports filed outside normal office hours.
  • The bill’s start date would depend on its effective date. Because it failed, those rules did not take effect.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make spending on mass communications more visible, including spending by noncommittee organizations.
  • A possible argument for the 24-hour deadline is that it would make some spending information available soon after the spending or obligation occurs.
  • Requiring the recipient and amount of committee spending could help readers see who paid for a communication and where the money went.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the 24-hour filing deadline and detailed contributor disclosures could impose a significant compliance burden, but the bill provides no cost estimate.
  • The undefined terms leave uncertainty about which communications trigger reporting, especially where the bill does not set a threshold for communications through other media.
  • The bill does not clearly explain how noncommittee filers must deal with anonymous contributions over $10, even though it bars them from accepting those contributions.