Mass-communication spending would require 24-hour reports

Summary#

SB-1158, titled “Reporting of mass communications,” would amend Wisconsin’s existing campaign-finance law in Chapter 11; it would not create a separate law or agency. Its stated goal is to require more reporting about mass communications and the money behind them. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • It would define a mass communication, including certain messages sent through media, 500 or more similar emails or faxes, 500 or more similar printed pieces, or 500 or more similar phone calls. It includes a narrow exception for a bona fide poll, but only if the listed election-period and candidate-reference conditions also apply.
  • Political action, independent expenditure, and recall committees would have to register after making a disbursement or taking on an obligation for a mass communication. They would have up to 10 business days after that to register. The bill would also keep the existing registration triggers described by the Legislative Reference Bureau.
  • Candidate committees, political parties, legislative campaign committees, political action committees, independent expenditure committees, and recall committees would have to include the date, amount, and recipient’s name and address for related payments or obligations in their campaign-finance reports.
  • A person other than an individual spending or committing at least $500 in total on a mass communication would have to report within 24 hours. The report would include information about contributors, the payment or obligation, and its recipient.
  • A committee or a person required to report under the bill could not accept an anonymous contribution over $10. The bill says committees must donate such a contribution to the common school fund or a charity; the rule for a noncommittee person is not clear.

What it means for you#

  • Committees and political parties: They would have to report mass-communication spending and obligations. Certain committees would also face a new registration trigger. The bill does not require them to get approval before communicating.
  • Organizations and other non-individual spenders: If they spent or committed $500 or more in total on a mass communication, they would have to report within 24 hours, including detailed contributor information. The bill does not impose this reporting duty on individuals.
  • Contributors: For reports under the new rule, a contributor’s name, address, and contribution amount would be itemized. An individual contributor’s occupation would also be reported if their cumulative contributions for the communication exceeded $200.
  • General public: The bill would not ban mass communications or change contribution limits. It would require reports to be filed, but the supplied material does not explain public access to those reports.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require reporting and, for some committees, registration, but it gives no estimate of added administrative or compliance costs.
  • It does not set an appropriation, fee, fine, or payment to a program.

What is unclear#

  • “Communications media” is not defined in the bill text supplied. The scope of that part of the mass-communication definition is therefore unclear.
  • The bill does not set out a filing form, reporting method, or process for handling missed or disputed reports.
  • It does not explain how the 24-hour deadline would work when the spending or obligation occurs outside ordinary business hours.
  • It requires noncommittee persons to report anonymous contributions over $10 and say whether they donated them, but the donation duty in the bill’s text applies expressly to committees.
  • The current text of Chapter 11 was not supplied, so the exact existing rules and the full extent of changes to current law could not be checked against the statutes.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make spending on mass political messages and the money supporting them easier to track.
  • Requiring reports within 24 hours from non-individual spenders could provide information sooner than waiting for a committee’s regular campaign-finance report.
  • Requiring the date, amount, and recipient for payments or obligations could help show who paid to produce or distribute a communication.

Case against#

  • One concern is that non-individual spenders could face a short 24-hour deadline and detailed reporting duties, without the bill spelling out the filing process.
  • The term “communications media” could leave uncertainty about which messages trigger reporting.
  • The bill requires disclosure of contributor details but does not explain public access, or how the rules apply to noncommittee persons who receive anonymous contributions over $10.
  • The bill gives no cost estimate for the added reporting and registration work.