Limit personalized algorithmic pricing of essentials

Summary#

SB 1140 would create a new section of Wisconsin law restricting personalized algorithmic pricing of essential consumer goods; it does not amend an existing Act. Its goal is to limit certain uses of personal data to set prices. The bill failed, so it did not become law.

  • Grocery retailers could use personalized algorithmic pricing only if the price carried a disclosure in the same size, format, color and field of vision as the price.
  • A grocery retailer could not use that pricing if the price could vary based partly or wholly on a consumer’s listed characteristics, including race, sex, disability or national origin.
  • A grocery retailer could not buy or otherwise acquire personal information from a data broker for use in pricing essential consumer goods.
  • In grocery stores of at least 15,000 square feet, retailers could not electronically display an algorithmically set price in the same field of vision as the product.
  • The Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection (DATCP) could make rules. DATCP, the Department of Justice, and district attorneys could enforce the law; affected people could sue for damages.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: If the bill had become law, covered prices set using real-time processing of consumer data would need the stated disclosure. This could let shoppers know when such pricing was used, but would not guarantee a single price for everyone.
  • Consumers: Retailers could not vary these prices based on the listed characteristics. The bill would not ban all uses of algorithms to set prices, or all price differences.
  • Consumers: A person aggrieved by a violation could bring a civil action for damages. If they prevailed, the court would have to award their costs, including reasonable attorney fees.
  • Grocery retailers: The rules would apply to retailers that sell essential consumer goods in Wisconsin and get more than half their annual revenue from packaged food products. The electronic-display restriction would apply only in stores at least 15,000 square feet in size.
  • Grocery retailers: The bill excludes price adjustments from promotions, loyalty programs or other temporary discounts broadly offered to attract or retain customers from its definition of personalized algorithmic pricing.
  • Enforcement agencies: DATCP and the Department of Justice could investigate, seek documents and testimony, and bring enforcement actions. District attorneys could bring actions after consulting DATCP.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would allow forfeitures of up to $1,000 per violation; for a knowing violation, the forfeiture would be $1,000 to $2,000 per violation.
  • It would allow state enforcement actions to seek injunctions, restitution where appropriate, and penalties. It would not set an appropriation or staffing level for enforcement or rule-making.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not give a start date that could take effect after it failed. Its proposed effective date depended on publication.
  • It does not explain how a retailer should determine whether a price was set “in whole or in part” using personalized algorithmic pricing, or how violations would be counted.
  • The bill does not set procedures, deadlines or appeals for investigations or enforcement.
  • It does not say how DATCP would use its rule-making power or what rules it might make.
  • The supplied material does not establish how the bill would interact with existing laws or programs. No publicly available information.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that shoppers should be told when personal data is used to set the price of everyday goods.
  • Banning price variation based on listed personal characteristics could limit a specific form of unequal treatment.
  • Restricting retailers’ purchase of consumer information from data brokers for pricing would address one identified source of data.
  • Enforcement powers and a private right to sue could provide ways to investigate violations and seek remedies.

Case against#

  • The bill does not ban personalized algorithmic pricing outright; the disclosure rule would allow it in many cases. A possible concern is that the disclosure may not tell shoppers how their data affected the price.
  • The definition excludes broadly offered temporary discounts, but does not explain how to distinguish those discounts from covered pricing in every case.
  • The bill gives agencies broad investigative powers but does not set investigation procedures, timelines or reporting requirements.
  • The bill does not estimate the cost of compliance, enforcement or rule-making, so those costs are unknown.