Fire-EMS district could levy taxes

Summary#

SB 1148, titled “Authorizing the creation of an emergency services district, authorizing an emergency services district to levy a property tax, and authorizing an emergency services district to impose special charges and issue debt,” would create a new kind of local government in Wisconsin. It would create a new law and amend existing statutes. Its stated goal is to let cities, villages, and towns jointly provide fire protection, emergency medical services (EMS), or both; the bill failed and is not law.

  • Two or more municipalities could form a district. It would be a separate unit of government, independent of the state and its member municipalities.
  • The district would be run by an elected board of 5 to 9 members. The board could hire staff, set their pay, and use volunteer firefighters and EMS workers.
  • A district could levy property taxes, charge fees for services, and borrow or issue municipal bonds for capital improvements. A fee used instead of a property tax would need voter approval in every member municipality.
  • Member municipalities would have to transfer real property and related attachments used for the district’s services, vehicles and specialized equipment worth at least $20,000, and related debt. Other assets could be transferred, sold, leased, or donated.
  • For the first five years, a panel of member municipalities’ chief executives could veto certain district actions identified in the formation agreement. The district board could override a veto with a two-thirds vote.

What it means for you#

  • Residents and property owners: If your municipality joined a district, the district could tax taxable property in the district. The bill does not set a tax rate. A district could instead charge a fee for protection services, but only after referendums in every member municipality.
  • Municipalities: A municipality joining a district would have to include all its territory, and its territory could be in only one district. It would have to reduce its own levy for services transferred to the district. Municipalities could contract with a district for services without joining it.
  • Municipal employees: If the district hired for the same or a substantially similar function, employees of member municipalities doing that work would have to be offered jobs in order of aggregate seniority. Certain existing collective bargaining terms would continue until the agreement expires or a district agreement is adopted, whichever comes first.
  • Fire and EMS providers: The district could provide either service or both. The bill would allow districts to receive certain state fire department dues, subject to requirements. It would not require every municipality to join a district.
  • General public: The bill would not itself guarantee a particular level of service or create a process for residents to apply for services.

Money#

The bill authorizes district taxes, fees, and borrowing, but no cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • A district’s property tax levy could increase each year only by its valuation factor, under rules like those for towns. A district’s initial budget would be limited by the prior-year appropriations of its founding municipalities for the services being transferred.
  • Member municipalities would have to lower their levies for services the district takes over. The bill does not provide a tax rate or estimate the net effect on taxpayers.
  • A fee in place of a property tax could not raise more than the property tax raised in the last year it was imposed.
  • The bill permits borrowing or municipal bonds for capital improvements. No borrowing limit or debt-cost estimate is given.
  • The bill would require transferred assets and associated debt, but the supplied material does not estimate their value.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text ends before the full district powers and rules. The Legislative Reference Bureau analysis describes the main provisions, but the full text was not available to check.
  • The supplied material does not include the full current statutes being amended. The analysis summarizes current law, but the complete comparison with existing law could not be verified.
  • The bill does not set district staffing levels, operating budgets, service standards, or how a district would decide what services to provide.
  • The municipalities’ formation agreement would set which issues are subject to veto, but the bill does not name those issues.
  • The amount of tax, fees, debt, transferred assets, and any effect on service costs are not estimated in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • A separate district could give multiple municipalities one governing body to organize fire protection or EMS, rather than relying only on contracts or joint arrangements.
  • The district could hire staff, own service-related property, and raise revenue directly. That could make it easier to organize services across municipal boundaries.
  • The bill limits annual property-tax levy increases and requires municipalities to reduce their levies for services transferred to the district.
  • The bill provides for employee job offers and continuation of certain collective bargaining terms during a transition.

Case against#

  • A district would gain authority to tax property, charge fees, and issue debt. The bill materials provide no estimate of the amount residents might pay.
  • Required transfers of property, equipment, and related debt could shift significant assets and obligations from municipalities to a new government.
  • The bill leaves many service and budget decisions to the district board and formation agreement, without specifying service standards or resident oversight beyond elected board members.
  • A veto panel would apply only for five years, and the district board could override a veto with a two-thirds vote. The bill does not say which decisions must be subject to veto.